Wickenberg Leah, Gabrie Katherine, McCarthy Patrick, Cain Melissa
Phigenics Research and Innovation Team, Phigenics, LLC, 3S701 West Ave Suite 100, Warrenville, IL,USA.
J AOAC Int. 2024 Jan 4;107(1):120-128. doi: 10.1093/jaoacint/qsad112.
Phigenics Validation Test (PVT) VIABLE® (Viability Identification Assay by Legionella Enrichment) is a method to detect viable Legionella bacteria in building water systems.
To evaluate PVT VIABLE against the ISO 11731:2017 Water Quality-Enumeration of Legionella reference method for the detection of viable Legionella species in potable and non-potable water.
PVT VIABLE was tested for inclusivity (n = 50 strains of Legionella) and exclusivity (n = 30 non-target strains), robustness, and stability. A multi-laboratory instrument variation study was performed to evaluate the PCR data. The matrix study was performed on potable and non-potable water samples inoculated with Legionella pneumophila at a low (n = 20) and high fractional level (n = 5). Samples were analyzed using the PVT VIABLE and confirmed using ISO 11731:2017.
Statistical analysis showed no difference between PVT VIABLE and ISO 11731:2017 for 100 mL test portions of potable and non-potable water. PVT VIABLE demonstrated high levels of specificity and sensitivity in the inclusivity and exclusivity study. Results of the robustness and stability studies demonstrated the method was sufficiently robust to handle small method changes and met the method claims of stability.
PVT VIABLE allows the end user to obtain presumptive results for viable Legionella spp. contamination of potable and non-potable water in 2-3 days.
PVT VIABLE provides viable Legionella results in 2-3 days versus 10-14 days for traditional spread plating. This novel diagnostic tool also differentiates between Legionella pneumophila sg1, Legionella pneumophila sg2-15, and Legionella spp. without the need for additional confirmation steps as outlined in ISO 11731:2017.
Phigenics验证测试(PVT)VIABLE®(通过军团菌富集进行生存力鉴定分析)是一种检测建筑水系统中活军团菌的方法。
对照ISO 11731:2017《水质 - 军团菌计数》参考方法,评估PVT VIABLE用于检测饮用水和非饮用水中活军团菌种类的性能。
对PVT VIABLE进行了包容性(n = 50株军团菌)、排他性(n = 30株非目标菌株)、稳健性和稳定性测试。进行了多实验室仪器变异研究以评估PCR数据。在接种了低(n = 20)和高比例水平(n = 5)嗜肺军团菌的饮用水和非饮用水样本上进行了基质研究。使用PVT VIABLE对样本进行分析,并使用ISO 11731:2017进行确认。
统计分析表明,对于100 mL的饮用水和非饮用水测试部分,PVT VIABLE与ISO 11731:2017之间没有差异。PVT VIABLE在包容性和排他性研究中表现出高水平的特异性和敏感性。稳健性和稳定性研究结果表明,该方法足够稳健,能够处理小的方法变化,并符合稳定性的方法要求。
PVT VIABLE使最终用户能够在2 - 3天内获得关于饮用水和非饮用水中活军团菌属污染的推定结果。
PVT VIABLE在2 - 3天内提供活军团菌检测结果,而传统平板涂布法需要10 - 14天。这种新型诊断工具还能区分嗜肺军团菌1型、嗜肺军团菌2 - 15型和其他军团菌属,无需ISO 11731:2017中概述的额外确认步骤。