Guttmacher Institute, 125 Maiden Lane, 7th Floor, New York, NY, USA.
Guttmacher Institute, 125 Maiden Lane, 7th Floor, New York, NY, USA.
Soc Sci Med. 2023 Oct;335:116216. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2023.116216. Epub 2023 Sep 5.
Anti-abortion legislation in the United States exploits misinformation and ignores medical definitions to curtail access to essential healthcare. Little is known about how individuals most likely to need this care define abortion, in general or as distinct from miscarriage, and how this might impact access to, utilization of, and experiences of care. Using mixed-method card sort and vignette data from cognitive interviews (n = 64) and a national online survey (n = 2009), we examined individuals' understandings of pregnancy outcomes including abortion and miscarriage. Our findings show that people hold varying ideas of what constitutes an abortion. Many respondents considered 'intent' when classifying pregnancy outcomes and focused on intervention to distinguish between miscarriages and abortions. Particularly, medical intervention was found as a defining feature of abortion. Lack of knowledge regarding pregnancy experiences and ambiguity surrounding early stages of pregnancy also influenced respondents' understanding of abortion. We find that abortion and miscarriage definitions are socially constructed and multi-layered. Advancing our understanding of abortion and miscarriage definitions improves reproductive health research by elucidating potential areas of confusion that may lead to misreporting of reproductive experiences as well as highlighting ways that blurred definitions may be exploited by abortion opponents.
美国的反堕胎立法利用错误信息,无视医学定义,限制了获得基本医疗保健的机会。人们对最有可能需要这种护理的个人如何定义堕胎(一般而言或与流产不同)知之甚少,以及这可能如何影响获得、利用和护理体验。我们使用认知访谈(n=64)和全国在线调查(n=2009)的混合方法卡片分类和小插图数据,研究了个人对包括堕胎和流产在内的妊娠结局的理解。我们的研究结果表明,人们对堕胎的定义存在不同的看法。许多受访者在对妊娠结局进行分类时考虑到“意图”,并侧重于干预措施来区分流产和堕胎。特别是,医疗干预被认为是堕胎的一个决定性特征。缺乏关于妊娠经历的知识以及对妊娠早期的模糊认识也影响了受访者对堕胎的理解。我们发现,堕胎和流产的定义是社会构建的,具有多层次性。通过阐明可能导致生殖经历错误报告的潜在困惑领域,并强调模糊定义可能被堕胎反对者利用的方式,我们对堕胎和流产定义的理解得到了提高。