Medical Ethics and Law Research Center, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Department of Medical Education, Faculty of Medicine, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
BMC Med Educ. 2023 Sep 26;23(1):703. doi: 10.1186/s12909-023-04695-2.
It is necessary to improve medical students' legal cognitive, affective, and psychomotor skills to prevent further legal issues in the medical profession. Choosing the proper teaching and assessment methods is crucial in this matter. This study aimed to investigate the impact of teaching, learning, and assessment of medical law on the cognitive, affective, and psychomotor skills of medical students.
A systematic review was conducted in PubMed, Embass, and Web of Science databases, and Google Scholar search engine using MECIR and PRISMA, AMEE Guide 94 for 1980 to 2022.12.30. Nineteen articles met the inclusion criteria. MERSQI checklist was used to assess the quality of the articles, and URSEC (theoretical underpinning of the development, resources required, setting, educational methods employed, and content) used to assess the risk of educational bias.
Internship courses called Medical Education Humanities and Society (MESH), clinical scenario design, seminars and small group discussions, web-based interactive training, legal training courses, PBL, and mind maps have been used to improve the medico-legal knowledge of medical students. MESH clerkship, simulation of a legal event, medico-legal advocacy program based on interdisciplinary education, group discussion, integration, and court-based learning used to improve student attitudes. Multidisciplinary training, small group discussions after the seminar, mock trial competition, and interdisciplinary education are used to teach psychomotor skills. All studies, except one on knowledge, reported positive effects of legal education on students' knowledge, attitudes, and legal performance. Written assessments were used for cognitive and affective domains, while performance was assessed by OSCE, simulated court, and evaluation of patient referrals.
There are few studies to examine the cognitive, affective, and legal psychomotor skills of medical students. The texts have not yet fully explored the high level of affective and psychomotor domains, which is evidence of a gap in this sector. Recognizing that medico-legal problems are prevented through proper education and assessment, it is recommended that this area be considered a research priority and that effective educational policies are adopted.
提高医学生的法律认知、情感和心理运动技能对于防止医学领域出现更多法律问题至关重要。选择适当的教学和评估方法在此至关重要。本研究旨在调查医学法律的教学、学习和评估对医学生认知、情感和心理运动技能的影响。
在 PubMed、Embase 和 Web of Science 数据库以及 Google Scholar 搜索引擎中,使用 MECIR 和 PRISMA、AMEE Guide 94 进行了系统综述,检索时间为 1980 年至 2022 年 12 月 30 日。符合纳入标准的有 19 篇文章。使用 MERSQI 清单评估文章质量,使用 URSEC(发展的理论基础、所需资源、设置、所采用的教育方法和内容)评估教育偏差风险。
使用实习课程(称为医学教育人文与社会(MESH))、临床情景设计、研讨会和小组讨论、基于网络的互动培训、法律培训课程、PBL 和思维导图来提高医学生的医学法律知识。MESH 实习、法律事件模拟、基于跨学科教育的医学法律倡导计划、小组讨论、整合和法庭学习用于改善学生态度。多学科培训、研讨会后的小组讨论、模拟审判竞赛和跨学科教育用于教授心理运动技能。除了一项关于知识的研究外,所有研究都报告了法律教育对学生知识、态度和法律表现的积极影响。书面评估用于认知和情感领域,而表现则通过 OSCE、模拟法庭和患者转诊评估来评估。
很少有研究来检验医学生的认知、情感和法律心理运动技能。这些文本尚未充分探索情感和心理运动领域的高级水平,这表明该领域存在差距。认识到通过适当的教育和评估可以预防医学法律问题,建议将该领域作为研究重点,并采取有效的教育政策。