Hull Katherine L, McIntyre Chris, Burton James O
Department of Cardiovascular Sciences, University of Leicester.
John Walls Renal Unit, University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust, Leicester, UK.
Curr Opin Nephrol Hypertens. 2023 Nov 1;32(6):537-543. doi: 10.1097/MNH.0000000000000917. Epub 2023 Aug 7.
There is an excess of cardiovascular morbidity and mortality in the maintenance haemodialysis population. Targeting traditional risk factors (e.g. hypercholesterolaemia) do not improve cardiovascular outcomes. Repeated myocardial stunning during haemodialysis is an important nontraditional risk, resulting in pathological cardiac remodelling and fibrosis. This review explores dialysate cooling as a management strategy to promote haemodynamic stability, reduce myocardial injury, and improve cardiovascular disease outcomes for individuals receiving maintenance haemodialysis.
Observational data and small interventional studies demonstrate dialysate cooling has the potential to reduce end-organ damage and provide cardioprotection, renal protection and neuroprotection compared with standard care. These data are limited by the small sample sizes, short follow-up times and lack of long-term patient important outcomes. The MyTEMP study, a multicentre pragmatic randomized controlled trial, demonstrated cooled dialysate (0.5°C below body temperature) vs. standard care did not improve cardiovascular outcomes for prevalent haemodialysis patients.
Dialysate cooling has been widely adopted into routine clinical practice; the MyTEMP study challenges the unit-level approach to implementing dialysate cooling. Due to methodological limitations, the absence of other important patient outcome measures, and lack of granularity of patient-level data, dialysate cooling should not be hastily removed from all dialysis care and warrants further research.
维持性血液透析人群存在过量的心血管发病率和死亡率。针对传统风险因素(如高胆固醇血症)并不能改善心血管结局。血液透析期间反复出现的心肌顿抑是一个重要的非传统风险,会导致病理性心脏重塑和纤维化。本综述探讨透析液冷却作为一种管理策略,以促进接受维持性血液透析的个体的血流动力学稳定性、减少心肌损伤并改善心血管疾病结局。
观察性数据和小型干预性研究表明,与标准治疗相比,透析液冷却有可能减少终末器官损伤,并提供心脏保护、肾脏保护和神经保护。这些数据受样本量小、随访时间短以及缺乏长期患者重要结局的限制。MyTEMP研究是一项多中心实用随机对照试验,结果表明,对于现患血液透析患者,冷却透析液(低于体温0.5°C)与标准治疗相比并未改善心血管结局。
透析液冷却已被广泛应用于常规临床实践;MyTEMP研究对实施透析液冷却的单位层面方法提出了挑战。由于方法学上的局限性、缺乏其他重要的患者结局指标以及患者层面数据缺乏粒度,不应匆忙取消所有透析治疗中的透析液冷却,仍需进一步研究。