Shahbaz Reemal, Williams Allison, Sethi Bharati, Wahoush Olive
Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University, Hamilton, ON L8S 4L8, Canada.
Faculty of Sciences, McMaster University, Hamilton, ON L8S 4L8, Canada.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2023 Sep 21;20(18):6800. doi: 10.3390/ijerph20186800.
This qualitative study explored the commonalities and differences among the experiences of visible minority Transnational Carer-Employees (TCEs) before and after COVID-19. TCEs are immigrants who live and work in the country of settlement while providing caregiving across international borders. Purposive and snowball sampling resulted in the participation of 29 TCEs of Pakistani, Syrian, African, and South American origin living in London, Ontario. Thematic analysis of the dataset using the ATLAS.ti software, Version 23.2.1., generated three themes: (1) feelings associated with transnational care; (2) employment experiences of TCEs; and (3) coping strategies for well-being. The results of the secondary analysis conducted herein suggested that there are more similarities than differences across the four cohorts. Many participants felt a sense of satisfaction at being able to fulfill their care obligations; however, a different outlook was observed among some Syrian and African origin respondents, who disclosed that managing care and work is overwhelming. Most TCEs also reported facing limited job options because of language barriers. While various interviewees experienced a lack of paid work and reduced income after COVID-19, a distinct perspective was noted from African descent TCEs as they expressed facing increased work demands after the pandemic. Participants additionally revealed four common coping strategies such as keeping busy, praying, family support, and staying active. Study implications include the promotion of Carer-Friendly Workplace Policies (CFWPs) that can facilitate the welfare of unpaid caregivers. This research is important as it may inform policymakers to create opportunities that may not only foster economic stability of TCEs and the Canadian economy, but also contribute towards a more equitable society.
这项定性研究探讨了可见少数族裔跨国护理员工(TCEs)在新冠疫情前后经历的异同。TCEs是指那些在定居国生活和工作,同时跨境提供护理服务的移民。通过目的抽样和滚雪球抽样,来自巴基斯坦、叙利亚、非洲和南美、居住在安大略省伦敦市的29名TCEs参与了研究。使用ATLAS.ti软件23.2.1版本对数据集进行主题分析,得出了三个主题:(1)与跨国护理相关的感受;(2)TCEs的就业经历;(3)幸福安康的应对策略。本文进行的二次分析结果表明,四个队列之间的相似之处多于差异。许多参与者对能够履行护理义务感到满意;然而,一些叙利亚和非洲裔受访者有不同看法,他们表示管理护理和工作让人不堪重负。大多数TCEs还报告称,由于语言障碍,他们面临的工作选择有限。虽然许多受访者在新冠疫情后经历了带薪工作机会缺乏和收入减少的情况,但非洲裔TCEs有不同的看法,因为他们表示疫情后工作需求增加。参与者还透露了四种常见的应对策略,如保持忙碌、祈祷、家庭支持和保持活跃。研究意义包括推广有利于护理人员的工作场所政策(CFWPs),以促进无薪护理人员的福利。这项研究很重要,因为它可能会为政策制定者提供信息,以创造不仅能促进TCEs和加拿大经济的经济稳定,而且有助于实现更公平社会的机会。