Suppr超能文献

美国五个地理区域心血管病专科培训项目之间的多样性差异

Diversity Differences Among Cardiovascular Fellowships Across Five Geographic Regions in the United States.

作者信息

Dye Makenzie, Saeed Azl, Nguyen Trang Q, Yu Sarah, Bey Jerome, Hefner Dylan, Walk Casey T, Lantz Rebekah

机构信息

College of Medicine, Wright State University Boonshoft School of Medicine, Fairborn, USA.

Surgery, Wright State University, Dayton, USA.

出版信息

Cureus. 2023 Aug 27;15(8):e44217. doi: 10.7759/cureus.44217. eCollection 2023 Aug.

Abstract

Introduction Diversity and inclusion in cardiovascular fellowships are necessary for addressing the healthcare needs of diverse patient populations. However, regional disparities in the diversity of these programs persist, diminishing efforts to create a representative workforce. We observe the regional differences in the diversity of cardiovascular fellowship programs, focusing on gender, doctorate designation, and graduation within the United States (US) or other. We hypothesized that males, medical doctors (MD), and US graduates would be in majority across all regions. Methods Data for cardiovascular fellowships from the Fellowship and Residency Electronic Database Access (FREIDA) system for the matriculation year 2022-2023 was obtained to assess the representation of male vs female gender, MD vs osteopathic doctor (DO) designation, and US vs non-US graduate. We then compared these backgrounds to five defined regions (Midwest, Northeast, Southeast, Southwest, and West) in the United States to define representation for backgrounds across geographic areas. Statistical significance was determined by p<0.05 with the use of SAS Studio 3.8, version 9.4 (Cary, NC: SAS Institute, Inc.), and Wilson score for confidence intervals. Results We found significant disparities across all background factors for all regions. This includes that females, DOs, and non-US graduates were underrepresented among Midwest, Northeast, Southeast, Southwest, and West regions, and the p-value was <0.001 for all variations. Specifically for Midwest, the female frequency was 155 (23.81%; CI: 21, 27; p<0.001), DO frequency was 101 (15.51%; CI: 13, 19; p<0.001), and non-US graduate frequency was 206 (31.84%; CI: 28, 36; p<0.001). For Northeast, the female frequency was 231 (29.62; CI: 27, 33; p<0.001), DO frequency was 72 (9.22; CI: 7, 11; p<0.001), and non-US graduate frequency was 239 (30.68; CI 28, 34; p<0.001). For Southeast, the female frequency was 178 (25.99; CI: 23, 29; p<0.001), DO frequency was 67 (9.78; CI: 8, 12; p<0.001), and non-US graduate frequency 279 (41.46; CI: 38, 45; p<0.001). For Southwest, the female frequency was 74 (26.71; CI: 22, 32; p<0.001), DO frequency was 21 (7.58; CI 5, 11; p<0.001), and non-US graduate frequency was 110 (39.71; CI: 34,46; p<0.001). For West, the female frequency was 107 (31.75; CI 27, 37; p<0.001), DO frequency was 15 (4.45; CI: 3, 7; p<0.001), and non-US graduate frequency was 54 (16.07; CI: 13, 20; p<0.001). Conclusion We emphasize the regional disparities for females, DOs, and non-US graduates within cardiovascular fellowships in the past matriculation year. Understanding that we have not reached diversity goals allows for further reflection and implementation of targeted interventions and initiatives aimed at promoting equal opportunities for applicants. This is true for all regions of the United States. By addressing these disparities, fellowship programs can more effectively mirror the diverse patient populations they serve and foster a healthcare environment that is inclusive and accommodating. This, in turn, contributes to the overall enhancement of healthcare outcomes.

摘要

引言 心血管专科培训中的多样性和包容性对于满足不同患者群体的医疗需求至关重要。然而,这些项目在多样性方面的地区差异仍然存在,削弱了打造具有代表性劳动力队伍的努力。我们观察了心血管专科培训项目在多样性方面的地区差异,重点关注性别、博士学位类型以及在美国境内或其他地区毕业的情况。我们假设男性、医学博士(MD)以及美国毕业生在所有地区都占多数。

方法 从“奖学金与住院医师电子数据库访问”(FREIDA)系统获取2022 - 2023学年心血管专科培训的数据,以评估男性与女性、医学博士与整骨疗法医生(DO)学位类型以及美国毕业生与非美国毕业生的占比情况。然后,我们将这些背景信息与美国五个定义区域(中西部、东北部、东南部、西南部和西部)进行比较,以确定不同地理区域背景的占比情况。使用SAS Studio 3.8版本9.4(北卡罗来纳州卡里:SAS研究所)通过p<0.05确定统计学显著性,并使用威尔逊得分计算置信区间。

结果 我们发现所有地区在所有背景因素上都存在显著差异。这包括女性、整骨疗法医生以及非美国毕业生在中西部、东北部、东南部、西南部和西部地区的占比不足,所有差异的p值均<0.001。具体而言,对于中西部地区,女性频率为155(23.81%;置信区间:21, 27;p<0.001),整骨疗法医生频率为101(15.51%;置信区间:13, 19;p<0.001),非美国毕业生频率为206(31.84%;置信区间:28, 36;p<0.001)。对于东北部地区,女性频率为231(29.62;置信区间:27, 33;p<0.001),整骨疗法医生频率为72(9.22;置信区间:7, 11;p<0.001),非美国毕业生频率为239(30.68;置信区间28, 34;p<0.001)。对于东南部地区,女性频率为178(25.99;置信区间:23, 29;p<0.001),整骨疗法医生频率为67(9.78;置信区间:8, 12;p<0.001),非美国毕业生频率为279(41.46;置信区间:38, 45;p<0.001)。对于西南部地区,女性频率为74(26.71;置信区间:22, 32;p<0.001),整骨疗法医生频率为21(7.58;置信区间5, 11;p<0.001),非美国毕业生频率为110(39.71;置信区间:34, 46;p<0.001)。对于西部地区,女性频率为107(31.75;置信区间27, 37;p<0.001),整骨疗法医生频率为15(4.45;置信区间:3, 7;p<0.001),非美国毕业生频率为54(16.07;置信区间:13, 20;p<0.001)。

结论 我们强调了上一学年心血管专科培训中女性、整骨疗法医生和非美国毕业生存在的地区差异。认识到我们尚未实现多样性目标,有助于进一步反思并实施有针对性的干预措施和倡议,旨在为申请者提供平等机会。美国所有地区都是如此。通过解决这些差异,专科培训项目能够更有效地反映其服务的多样化患者群体,并营造一个包容且适宜的医疗环境。这反过来有助于全面提升医疗效果。

https://cdn.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/blobs/0599/10522360/41e3b06e1339/cureus-0015-00000044217-i01.jpg

文献检索

告别复杂PubMed语法,用中文像聊天一样搜索,搜遍4000万医学文献。AI智能推荐,让科研检索更轻松。

立即免费搜索

文件翻译

保留排版,准确专业,支持PDF/Word/PPT等文件格式,支持 12+语言互译。

免费翻译文档

深度研究

AI帮你快速写综述,25分钟生成高质量综述,智能提取关键信息,辅助科研写作。

立即免费体验