Wilson Christopher M, Boright Lori, Louie Wing-Yue Geoffrey, Shahverdi Pourya, Arena Sara K, Benbow Ronald, Wilson Jason R, Chen Qinghua, Rousso Katie, Huang Nathan
Physical Therapy, Oakland University, Rochester, USA.
Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Corewell Health, Southfield, USA.
Cureus. 2023 Aug 28;15(8):e44264. doi: 10.7759/cureus.44264. eCollection 2023 Aug.
Introduction The high prevalence of falls, lack of stability and balance, and general physical deconditioning are concerning issues for longevity and quality of life for adults aged 65 years and older. Although supervised delivery of the Otago Exercise Program (OEP) has demonstrated evidence of effectiveness in reducing fall risk of older adults, opportunities for ongoing unsupervised exercise performance are warranted. An option to facilitate exercise and performance of health behaviors may be via a social robot. The purpose of this study was to examine feasibility and initial outcomes of a robot-delivered fall prevention exercise program for community-dwelling older adults. Methods Five participants aged 65 years and older were recruited to receive robot-delivered modified OEP and walking program three times per week for four weeks. Outcomes of demographics, self-reported performance measures (Modified Falls Self-Efficacy Scale, Activities-specific Balance Confidence, and Almere Model assessing various constructs of acceptance of use of robotic technology), and physical performance measures (Timed Up and Go Test, Short Physical Performance Battery, Balance Tracking System [BTrackS] center of pressure sway) were collected. Data were analyzed descriptively and examined for trends in change. Measures of central tendency and distribution were used according to the distribution of the data. Results The mean age of the participants was 75 years (range: 66-83 years; four females and one male). The range of participant exercise session completion was 7-12 (mode=11, n=3). Constructs on the Almere Model that started and remained positive were Attitudes Toward Technology and Perceived Enjoyment with the robot. Anxiety improved from 3.80 to 4.68, while Social Presence of the robot improved from 2.80 to 3.56. The construct of Trust was somewhat negative among participants upon commencing the program and did not substantially change over time. Two participants improved their confidence on the Activities-specific Balance Confidence scale by more than 10%, while all participants showed some improvement in confidence in their balance. Mixed results were found with the Modified Falls Self-Efficacy Scale. Mean gait speed for the participants improved by 0.76 seconds over 3 meters. Improvement was also demonstrated for the Short Physical Performance Battery, with two participants improving scores by 2-3 points out of 12. No appreciable changes were found with the Timed Up and Go test and the BTrackS assessment. Conclusion Using a robot-led exercise program is an accessible and feasible way to deliver exercise to community-dwelling older adults in the home, but some technical constraints remain. Outcomes suggest that a four-week program is sufficient to elicit some positive trends in health outcomes and has the potential to reduce fall risk.
引言
跌倒的高发生率、缺乏稳定性和平衡能力以及身体普遍机能衰退,是65岁及以上成年人寿命和生活质量方面令人担忧的问题。尽管监督实施奥塔哥运动计划(OEP)已证明在降低老年人跌倒风险方面有效,但仍需要有机会进行持续的非监督运动。促进运动和健康行为表现的一种选择可能是通过社交机器人。本研究的目的是检验为社区居住的老年人提供的由机器人实施的预防跌倒运动计划的可行性和初步结果。
方法
招募了5名65岁及以上的参与者,让他们接受由机器人实施的改良OEP和步行计划,每周三次,共四周。收集了人口统计学数据、自我报告的表现指标(改良跌倒自我效能量表、特定活动平衡信心量表以及评估对机器人技术使用接受度的各种构念的阿尔梅勒模型)和身体表现指标(定时起立行走测试、简短身体表现量表、压力中心摆动平衡跟踪系统[BTrackS])。对数据进行描述性分析,并检查变化趋势。根据数据分布使用集中趋势和分布的测量方法。
结果
参与者的平均年龄为75岁(范围:66 - 83岁;4名女性和1名男性)。参与者完成运动课程的次数范围为7 - 12次(众数 = 11,n = 3)。阿尔梅勒模型中开始并保持积极的构念是对技术的态度和对机器人的感知乐趣。焦虑从3.80改善到4.68,而机器人的社交存在感从2.80改善到3.56。在开始该计划时,参与者中的信任构念有些负面,且随时间没有实质性变化。两名参与者在特定活动平衡信心量表上的信心提高了10%以上,而所有参与者在平衡信心方面都有一定改善。改良跌倒自我效能量表的结果喜忧参半。参与者的平均步态速度在3米的距离上提高了0.76秒。简短身体表现量表也显示出改善,两名参与者在12分的总分中提高了2 - 3分。定时起立行走测试和BTrackS评估没有发现明显变化。
结论
使用机器人主导的运动计划是一种在家庭中为社区居住的老年人提供运动的便捷且可行的方式,但仍存在一些技术限制。结果表明,为期四周的计划足以引发一些健康结果的积极趋势,并有降低跌倒风险的潜力。