Shubert Tiffany E, Basnett Jeanna, Chokshi Anang, Barrett Mark, Komatireddy Ravi
Shubert Consulting, Chapel Hill, NC, United States.
Reflexion Health, San Diego, CA, United States.
JMIR Rehabil Assist Technol. 2015 Nov 5;2(2):e10. doi: 10.2196/rehab.4776.
Falls in older adults are a significant public health issue. Interventions have been developed and proven effective to reduce falls in older adults, but these programs typically last several months and can be resource intensive. Virtual rehabilitation technologies may offer a solution to bring these programs to scale. Off-the-shelf and custom exergames have demonstrated to be a feasible adjunct to rehabilitation with older adults. However, it is not known if older adults will be able or willing to use a virtual rehabilitation technology to participate in an evidence-based fall prevention program. To have the greatest impact, virtual rehabilitation technologies need to be acceptable to older adults from different backgrounds and level of fall risk. If these technologies prove to be a feasible option, they offer a new distribution channel to disseminate fall prevention programs.
Stand Tall (ST) is a virtual translation of the Otago Exercise Program (OEP), an evidence-based fall prevention program. Stand Tall was developed using the Virtual Exercise Rehabilitation Assistant (VERA) software, which uses a Kinect camera and a laptop to deliver physical therapy exercise programs. Our purpose in this pilot study was to explore if ST could be a feasible platform to deliver the OEP to older adults from a variety of fall risk levels, education backgrounds, and self-described level of computer expertise.
Adults age 60 and over were recruited to participate in a one-time usability study. The study included orientation to the program, navigation to exercises, and completion of a series of strength and balance exercises. Quantitative analysis described participants and the user experience.
A diverse group of individuals participated in the study. Twenty-one potential participants (14 women, 7 men) met the inclusion criteria. The mean age was 69.2 (± 5.8) years, 38% had a high school education, 24% had a graduate degree, and 66% classified as "at risk for falls". Eighteen participants agreed they would like to use ST to help improve their balance, and 17 agreed or strongly agreed they would feel confident using the system in either the senior center or the home. Thirteen participants felt confident they could actually set up the system in their home. The mean System Usability Scale (SUS) score was 65.5 ± 21.2 with a range of 32.5 to 97.5. Ten participants scored ST as an above average usability experience compared to other technologies and 5 participants scored a less than optimal experience. Exploratory analysis revealed no significant relationships between user experience, education background, self-described computer experience, and fall risk.
Results support the virtual delivery of the OEP by a Kinect camera and an avatar may be acceptable to older adults from a variety of backgrounds. Virtual technologies, like Stand Tall, could offer an efficient and effective approach to bring evidence-based fall prevention programs to scale to address the problem of falls and fall-related injuries. Next steps include determining if similar or better outcomes are achieved by older adults using the virtual OEP, Stand Tall, compared to the standard of care.
老年人跌倒问题是一个重大的公共卫生问题。已经开发出一些干预措施并证明对减少老年人跌倒有效,但这些项目通常持续数月,且资源需求较大。虚拟康复技术可能为扩大这些项目的规模提供解决方案。现成的和定制的运动游戏已被证明是老年人康复的可行辅助手段。然而,尚不清楚老年人是否有能力或愿意使用虚拟康复技术参与循证预防跌倒项目。为了产生最大影响,虚拟康复技术需要被来自不同背景和跌倒风险水平的老年人所接受。如果这些技术被证明是可行的选择,它们将为传播预防跌倒项目提供一个新的渠道。
“站直了”(ST)是奥塔哥运动计划(OEP)的虚拟版本,OEP是一个循证预防跌倒项目。“站直了”是使用虚拟运动康复助手(VERA)软件开发的,该软件利用一台Kinect摄像头和一台笔记本电脑来提供物理治疗锻炼项目。我们在这项试点研究中的目的是探讨ST是否可以成为一个可行的平台,向来自不同跌倒风险水平、教育背景和自我描述的计算机专业水平的老年人提供OEP。
招募60岁及以上的成年人参加一次性的可用性研究。该研究包括项目介绍、锻炼导航以及完成一系列力量和平衡锻炼。定量分析描述了参与者和用户体验。
一群多样化的个体参与了该研究。21名潜在参与者(14名女性,7名男性)符合纳入标准。平均年龄为69.2(±5.8)岁,38%的人有高中学历,24%的人有研究生学位,66%的人被归类为“有跌倒风险”。18名参与者表示他们愿意使用ST来帮助改善平衡,17名参与者同意或强烈同意他们会有信心在老年中心或家中使用该系统。13名参与者觉得他们有信心在家中实际设置该系统。系统可用性量表(SUS)的平均得分为65.5±21.2,范围为32.5至97.5。与其他技术相比,10名参与者将ST评为高于平均水平的可用性体验,5名参与者的体验不太理想。探索性分析显示,用户体验、教育背景、自我描述的计算机体验和跌倒风险之间没有显著关系。
结果支持通过Kinect摄像头和虚拟形象以虚拟方式提供OEP可能被来自各种背景的老年人所接受。像“站直了”这样的虚拟技术可以提供一种高效有效的方法,将循证预防跌倒项目扩大规模,以解决跌倒及与跌倒相关的伤害问题。下一步包括确定使用虚拟OEP“站直了”的老年人与标准护理相比是否能取得相似或更好的结果。