Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, J. B. Speed School of Engineering, University of Louisville, 132 E. Pkwy., Louisville, KY 40202, United States.
Christina Lee Brown Envirome Institute, School of Medicine, University of Louisville, 302 E. Muhammad Ali Blvd., Louisville, KY 40202, United States.
Sci Total Environ. 2024 Jan 1;906:167375. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2023.167375. Epub 2023 Sep 27.
For wastewater sample collection approaches supporting public health applications, few high hydrologic activity normalizing guidelines currently consider readily available environmental flow data that may earlier capture information regarding periods of influent mixing and dilution of wastewater with groundwater and runoff. This study aimed to identify wastewater sampling rules for high hydrological activity events, allowing for an earlier decision point in the control of dilution before sample collection. We defined the sampling rules via data-driven models (Random Forest and linear regression) using environmental data (i.e., wastewater treatment facility influent rates, nearby stream discharge flow, and precipitation). These models were applied to five treatment plants in Jefferson County, Kentucky (USA) in mixed, separate, and combined sewers with different population sizes. We proposed cutoffs of 10 %, 25 %, and 50 % flow conditions for orientation towards public health samples. The results showed a strong nonlinear relationship between nearby stream discharge and treatment facility flow rates, which was used to infer the hydrological conditions that produce high volumes of diluted wastewater in the sewer system. Accumulated Local Effects and SHapley Additive exPlanations aided in deciphering the relationship between the predictors and response variables of the Random Forest models. The influent rate to the treatment plant from the previous day and two USGS stream gages were needed to adequately predict the degree of infiltration and inflow mixing on a given day. Surface water discharge data can be used to provide an earlier workflow decision point during wet weather periods to improve understanding of flow conditions for wastewater-based epidemiological studies to inform laboratory analysis and data interpretation. Not only total flow, but also the specific proportions of infiltration and inflow to wastewater volume in influent should be considered when analyzing data for normalization purposes, and our method provides a starting point for doing so rapidly and at low cost.
对于支持公共卫生应用的废水样本采集方法,目前很少有高水文活性归一化指南考虑到现成的环境流量数据,这些数据可能更早地捕获有关废水与地下水和径流混合和稀释时期的信息。本研究旨在确定高水文活性事件的废水采样规则,以便在采样前更早地控制稀释。我们使用环境数据(即废水处理厂进水率、附近溪流流量和降水)通过数据驱动模型(随机森林和线性回归)定义了采样规则。这些模型应用于肯塔基州杰斐逊县(美国)的五个处理厂,包括混合、单独和组合下水道,人口规模不同。我们提出了 10%、25%和 50%流量条件的截止值,以面向公共卫生样本。结果表明,附近溪流流量与处理厂流量之间存在很强的非线性关系,这用于推断在下水道系统中产生大量稀释废水的水文条件。累积局部效应和 SHapley 可加解释有助于破译随机森林模型的预测因子和响应变量之间的关系。前一天进入处理厂的进水率和两个 USGS 溪流计是预测给定日期下渗和入流混合程度所必需的。地表水排放数据可用于在潮湿天气期间提供更早的工作流程决策点,以更好地了解基于废水的流行病学研究的流量条件,为实验室分析和数据解释提供信息。在进行数据归一化分析时,不仅要考虑总流量,还要考虑进水中外渗和入流的特定比例对废水体积的影响,而我们的方法为快速且低成本地做到这一点提供了一个起点。