Health Management Center, The First Affiliated Hospital of Zhengzhou University, Zhengzhou, China.
College of Public Health, Zhengzhou University, Zhengzhou, China.
Epidemics. 2023 Dec;45:100719. doi: 10.1016/j.epidem.2023.100719. Epub 2023 Sep 26.
The corona virus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic has spread to more than 210 countries and regions around the world, with different characteristics recorded depending on the location. A systematic summarization of COVID-19 outbreaks that occurred during the "dynamic zero-COVID" policy period in Chinese mainland had not been previously conducted. In-depth mining of the big data from the past two years of the COVID-19 pandemics must be performed to clarify their epidemiological characteristics and dynamic transmissions.
Trajectory clustering was used to group epidemic and time-varying reproduction number (Rt) curves of mass outbreaks into different models and reveal the epidemiological characteristics and dynamic transmissions of COVID-19. For the selected single-peak epidemic curves, we constructed a peak-point judgment model based on the dynamic slope and adopted a single-peak fitting model to identify the key time points and peak parameters. Finally, we developed an extreme gradient boosting-based prediction model for peak infection cases based on the total number of infections on the first 3, 5, and 7 days of the initial average incubation period.
(1) A total of 7 52298 cases, including 587 outbreaks in 251 cities in Chinese mainland between June 11, 2020, and June 29, 2022, were collected, and the first wave of COVID-19 outbreaks was excluded. Excluding the Shanghai outbreak in 2022, the 586 remaining outbreaks resulted in 1 25425 infections, with an infection rate of 4.21 per 1 00000 individuals. The number of outbreaks varied based on location, season, and temperature. (2) Trajectory clustering analysis showed that 77 epidemic curves were divided into four patterns, which were dominated by two single-peak clustering patterns (63.3%). A total of 77 Rt curves were grouped into seven patterns, with the leading patterns including four downward dynamic transmission patterns (74.03%). These curves revealed that the interval from peak to the point where the Rt value dropped below 1 was approximately 5 days. (3) The peak-point judgment model achieved a better result in the area under the curve (0.96, 95% confidence interval = 0.90-1.00). The single-peak fitting results on the epidemic curves indicated that the interval from the slow-growth point to the sharp-decline point was approximately 4-6 days in more than 50% of mass outbreaks. (4) The peak-infection-case prediction model exhibited the superior clustering results of epidemic and Rt curves compared with the findings without grouping.
Overall, our findings suggest the variation in the infection rates during the "dynamic zero-COVID" policy period based on the geographic division, level of economic development, seasonal division, and temperature. Trajectory clustering can be a useful tool for discovering epidemiological characteristics and dynamic transmissions, judging peak points, and predicting peak infection cases using different patterns.
2019 年冠状病毒病(COVID-19)大流行已蔓延至全球 210 多个国家和地区,不同地区的特点也各不相同。此前,尚未对中国内地“动态清零”政策期间发生的 COVID-19 疫情进行系统总结。必须深入挖掘过去两年 COVID-19 大流行的大数据,以明确其流行病学特征和动态传播。
轨迹聚类用于将大规模疫情的疫情和时变繁殖数(Rt)曲线分组到不同模型中,以揭示 COVID-19 的流行病学特征和动态传播。对于选择的单峰疫情曲线,我们基于动态斜率构建了一个峰值判断模型,并采用单峰拟合模型来确定关键时间点和峰值参数。最后,我们基于初始平均潜伏期的前 3、5 和 7 天的总感染人数,开发了一个基于极端梯度增强的峰值感染病例预测模型。
(1)共收集 2020 年 6 月 11 日至 2022 年 6 月 29 日期间,中国大陆 251 个城市的 587 起疫情中,共 752298 例,排除了上海 2022 年疫情。586 起剩余疫情共导致 125425 例感染,感染率为每 100000 人 4.21 例。疫情数量因地点、季节和温度而异。(2)轨迹聚类分析表明,77 条疫情曲线分为四种模式,其中两种单峰聚类模式占主导地位(63.3%)。共对 77 条 Rt 曲线进行分组,分为七种模式,其中主导模式包括四种下降动态传播模式(74.03%)。这些曲线表明,从峰值到 Rt 值降至 1 以下的时间间隔约为 5 天。(3)峰点判断模型在曲线下面积(0.96,95%置信区间=0.90-1.00)方面取得了更好的结果。在超过 50%的大规模疫情中,疫情曲线的单峰拟合结果表明,从缓慢增长点到急剧下降点的时间间隔约为 4-6 天。(4)峰值感染病例预测模型与未分组的模型相比,在疫情和 Rt 曲线的聚类结果上表现出更好的效果。
总的来说,我们的研究结果表明,在“动态清零”政策期间,基于地理分区、经济发展水平、季节划分和温度,感染率存在差异。轨迹聚类可以成为一种有用的工具,用于发现流行病学特征和动态传播、判断峰值点以及使用不同模式预测峰值感染病例。