Department of Psychology, New York University.
Department of Psychology, University of New Hampshire.
J Exp Psychol Gen. 2024 Jan;153(1):1-14. doi: 10.1037/xge0001466. Epub 2023 Oct 5.
Girls and women are underrepresented in chess. Here, we explored the role of in this phenomenon. Specifically, we investigated whether parents and mentors (e.g., coaches) show bias against the female youth players in their lives. Parents and mentors ( = 286; 90.6% men) recruited through the U.S. Chess Federation reported their evaluations of and investment in youth players ( = 654). We found evidence of bias on some, but not all, measures. Most strikingly, parents and mentors thought that female youth players' highest potential chess ratings were on average lower than male players', a bias that was exacerbated among parents and mentors who believed that success in chess requires brilliance. In addition, mentors who endorsed (vs. rejected) this belief also reported that female mentees were more likely to drop out of chess due to low ability. These findings provide the first large-scale evidence of bias against youth female players and hold implications for the role of parents and mentors in other domains that, like chess, are culturally associated with intellectual ability and exhibit substantial gender imbalances (e.g., science and technology). (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved).
女孩和女性在国际象棋中代表性不足。在这里,我们探讨了这种现象背后的原因。具体来说,我们调查了父母和导师(如教练)是否对生活中的女性青年棋手存在偏见。我们通过美国国际象棋联合会招募了家长和导师(=286;90.6%为男性),让他们报告对青年棋手的评价和投资(=654)。我们发现,在一些方面存在偏见,但不是所有方面都存在偏见。最引人注目的是,家长和导师认为女性青年棋手的最高潜在国际象棋评级平均低于男性棋手,这种偏见在那些认为国际象棋成功需要天赋的家长和导师中更为严重。此外,支持(而非反对)这一信念的导师还报告说,由于能力较低,女性学员更有可能退出国际象棋。这些发现为针对青年女性棋手的偏见提供了首个大规模证据,并对父母和导师在其他领域的作用产生了影响,这些领域与智力能力相关,并且存在明显的性别失衡(例如科学和技术)。