Henes Melanie, Mann Ellen, Hirchenhain Christine, Bauer Emanuel, Kentner Alexander, Quaas Jens, Koßagk Christopher, Gallwas Julia, Henes Leon, Schumacher Antonia, Küppers Volkmar
Department für Frauengesundheit Tübingen, Universitätsfrauenklinik, Tübingen, Germany.
Universitätsfrauenklinik und Poliklinik am Klinikum Südstadt Rostock, Rostock, Germany.
Geburtshilfe Frauenheilkd. 2023 Oct 5;83(10):1250-1262. doi: 10.1055/a-2159-7510. eCollection 2023 Oct.
For the first time since 1971, new regulations were introduced for cervical cancer screening as an organized cancer screening guideline (oKFE-RL) starting 1 January 2020. From the age of 20, a cytological smear test is performed annually, and from the age of 35, so-called co-testing (cytology and test for high-risk HPVs) is performed every three years. In case of abnormalities, the algorithm is used as the basis for investigation. According to this diagnostic algorithm, even so-called low-risk groups receive early colposcopic evaluation. This approach has been heavily debated and serves as the basis for this registry study.
All patients who presented to the centers for a colposcopy as part of the diagnostic algorithm were included after signing an informed consent form. The following findings were obtained: Medical history, colposcopy, histology, and cytology findings, as well as possible therapies and their findings. The aim was to evaluate the frequency of the target lesions cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) 2+/CIN 3+ in the respective groups.
A total of 4763 patients were enrolled in the study from July 2020 to October 2022. As a referral diagnosis, HPV persistence (HPV: human papillomavirus) with group I was determined in 23.9% (1139), HPV persistence with group II-a in 2.1% (100), II-p (ASC-US) in 11.2% (535), and II-g (AGC endocervical NOS) in 1.3% (64). III-p (ASC-H) and III-g (AGC endocervical favor neoplastic) were found in 9.4% (447) and 2.2% (107), respectively, IIID1 (LSIL) in 19% (906), IIID2 (HSIL, moderate dysplasia) in 18.9% (898), IVa-p (HSIL, severe dysplasia) in 10.7% (508), IVa-g (AIS) in 0.7% (31), IVb-p (HSIL with features suspicious for invasion) and IVb-g (AIS with features suspicious for invasion) in 0.3% (15), 0.1% (6), and 7 with suspected invasion V-p (squamous cell carcinoma)/V-g (endocervical adenocarcinoma) (0.1%). In the IVa-p group (HSIL, severe dysplasia), 67.7% had CIN 2+ and 56.5% had CIN 3+, adenocarcinoma in situ (AIS), and adenocarcinoma. If the histology of the excised tissue specifically based on the colposcope findings was also evaluated, CIN 2+ was found in 79.7% of cases, and CIN 3+ in 67.3% of cases. In IIID2 (HSIL, moderate dysplasia), CIN 2+ was detected in 50.9%, and CIN 3+/AIS in 28.3%. After evaluating patients who underwent surgery immediately, this increased to 53.0% for CIN 2+ and 29.3% for CIN 3+/AIS. In IIID1 (LSIL), CIN 2+ was detected in 27.4% and CIN 3+/AIS in 11.7%, and in II-p (ASC-US), CIN 2+ was detected in 23.4% and CIN 3+ and AIS in 10.8%, and in II-g (AGC endocervical NOS), CIN 2+ was detected in 34.4% and CIN 3+ in 23.4%. In the HPV persistence/II-a and I group, 21% showed CIN 2+, and 12.1% showed CIN 3+ and AIS, and 13% showed CIN 2+ and 5.9% showed CIN 3+ and AIS. In patients who were HPV-negative and had further diagnostics performed on the basis of cytologic smear alone, 27.9% had CIN 2+, and 14.1% had CIN 3 and AIS.
In a synopsis of the present findings of our initial data of the registry study on the new cervical cancer screening, according to the organized early cancer screening guideline (oKFE-RL), we could show that the target lesion CIN 3+ and AIS is detected unexpectedly frequently in a not insignificant proportion, especially in the cytological low-risk group. Currently, we cannot answer whether this can reduce the incidence and mortality of cervical carcinoma, but this could be an initial indication of this and will be reviewed in further long-term evaluations.
自1971年以来,首次出台了新的宫颈癌筛查规定,作为一项有组织的癌症筛查指南(oKFE-RL),于2020年1月1日起实施。从20岁起,每年进行一次细胞学涂片检查;从35岁起,每三年进行一次所谓的联合检测(细胞学检查和高危人乳头瘤病毒检测)。如发现异常,则以该算法为调查依据。根据这一诊断算法,即使是所谓的低风险人群也会接受早期阴道镜评估。这种方法引发了激烈争论,并成为本登记研究的基础。
所有作为诊断算法一部分到各中心接受阴道镜检查的患者,在签署知情同意书后被纳入研究。获得了以下结果:病史、阴道镜检查、组织学和细胞学检查结果,以及可能的治疗方法及其结果。目的是评估各亚组中目标病变宫颈上皮内瘤变(CIN)2+/CIN 3+的发生率。
2020年7月至2022年10月,共有4763例患者纳入本研究。作为转诊诊断,I组中23.9%(1139例)确定为HPV持续感染(HPV:人乳头瘤病毒),II-a组中2.1%(100例)、II-p(非典型鳞状细胞未明确意义,ASC-US)组中11.2%(535例)、II-g(宫颈管腺上皮细胞非特异性腺瘤样增生,AGC endocervical NOS)组中1.3%(64例)为HPV持续感染。III-p(非典型鳞状细胞不排除高度病变,ASC-H)和III-g(宫颈管腺上皮细胞倾向肿瘤性病变,AGC endocervical favor neoplastic)分别占9.4%(447例)和2.2%(107例),IIID1(低级别鳞状上皮内病变,LSIL)占19%(906例),IIID2(高级别鳞状上皮内病变,中度发育异常,HSIL)占18.9%(898例),IVa-p(HSIL,重度发育异常)占10.7%(508例),IVa-g(原位腺癌,AIS)占0.7%(31例),IVb-p(具有侵袭可疑特征的HSIL)和IVb-g(具有侵袭可疑特征的AIS)分别占0.3%(15例)、0.1%(6例),7例怀疑有侵袭性V-p(鳞状细胞癌)/V-g(宫颈管腺癌)(0.1%)。在IVa-p组(HSIL,重度发育异常)中,67.7%有CIN 2+,56.5%有CIN 3+、原位腺癌(AIS)和腺癌。如果根据阴道镜检查结果对切除组织的组织学进行评估,79.7%的病例发现有CIN 2+,67.3%的病例发现有CIN 3+。在IIID2(HSIL,中度发育异常)中,50.9%检测到CIN 2+,28.3%检测到CIN 3+/AIS。对立即接受手术的患者进行评估后,CIN 2+升至53.0%,CIN 3+/AIS升至29.3%。在IIID1(LSIL)中,27.4%检测到CIN 2+,11.7%检测到CIN 3+/AIS;在II-p(ASC-US)中,23.4%检测到CIN 2+,10.8%检测到CIN 3+和AIS;在II-g(AGC endocervical NOS)中,34.4%检测到CIN 2+,23.4%检测到CIN 3+。在HPV持续感染/II-a和I组中,21%显示有CIN 2+,12.1%显示有CIN 3+和AIS;13%显示有CIN 2+,5.9%显示有CIN 3+和AIS。在HPV阴性且仅根据细胞学涂片进行进一步诊断的患者中,27.9%有CIN 2+,14.1%有CIN 3和AIS。
在对新宫颈癌筛查登记研究的初始数据的当前结果进行总结时,根据有组织的早期癌症筛查指南(oKFE-RL),我们可以表明,目标病变CIN 3+和AIS在相当比例的人群中被意外频繁检测到,尤其是在细胞学低风险组中。目前,我们无法回答这是否能降低宫颈癌的发病率和死亡率,但这可能是一个初步迹象,将在进一步的长期评估中进行审查。