Department of Education and Psychology, Centro Universitario Cardenal Cisneros, Alcalá de Henares, Spain.
School of Human and Social Sciences, Department of Psychology, Universidad Pontificia Comillas, Madrid, Spain.
Eur J Psychotraumatol. 2023;14(2):2263320. doi: 10.1080/20008066.2023.2263320. Epub 2023 Oct 10.
The Posttraumatic Growth Inventory (PTGI) and its Short Form (PTGI-SF) are two instruments highly used in research on posttraumatic growth. They include a religious growth item that has been demonstrated to be problematic in cultures that are not very religious. Previous research has addressed this issue in other countries, but no attention has been paid to this critical problem in Spanish samples. Our aim is to address the psychometric issues presented by the religious growth item in Spain. To do so, we reviewed several studies conducted with various populations in Spain. The scores of the religious growth item in Spain present very low means and standard deviations, as well as high skewness and kurtosis, all of which point to a floor effect. The item scores show low item-test correlations, and it has failed to load on a specific dimension in factor analyses, thus casting doubts about its validity. The inventory does not seem to work properly in its current form in Spain. The inappropriateness of the item measuring religious growth in Spain may be due to cultural reasons. We recommend using the PTGI expanded version (PTGI-X) instead of the PTGI and exploring the possible substitution of the religious growth item in the PTGI-SF for an alternative item. In both cases, ascertaining the psychometric properties of the scores in Spain will be necessary.
创伤后成长量表(PTGI)及其简式量表(PTGI-SF)是用于创伤后成长研究的两种常用工具。它们包含一个宗教成长项目,该项目在宗教信仰不那么浓厚的文化中已被证明存在问题。先前的研究已经在其他国家解决了这个问题,但西班牙样本中并没有关注这个关键问题。我们的目的是解决西班牙的宗教成长项目在心理测量学上的问题。为此,我们回顾了在西班牙不同人群中进行的几项研究。在西班牙,宗教成长项目的得分呈现出非常低的均值和标准差,以及较高的偏度和峰度,所有这些都指向地板效应。项目得分显示出较低的项目与测试的相关性,并且在因素分析中未能加载到特定维度上,从而对其有效性产生了怀疑。该量表在西班牙目前的形式下似乎不能正常工作。在西班牙,衡量宗教成长的项目不适用可能是由于文化原因。我们建议使用扩展版的 PTGI(PTGI-X)代替 PTGI,并探索在 PTGI-SF 中用替代项目替代宗教成长项目的可能性。在这两种情况下,都需要确定在西班牙的量表得分的心理测量学特性。