Kaneda K, Naito S, Imaizumi S, Yano I, Mizuno S, Tomiyasu I, Baba T, Kusunose E, Kusunose M
J Clin Microbiol. 1986 Dec;24(6):1060-70. doi: 10.1128/jcm.24.6.1060-1070.1986.
The molecular species composition of alpha-mycolic acids ranging from C68 to C86 in 13 rapidly growing and 12 slowly growing mycobacterial species was determined by gas chromatography, gas chromatography-mass spectrometry, and mass chromatography. In gas chromatographic analysis, the molecular species of alpha-mycolic acids were well separated as trimethylsilyl ether derivatives of the methyl esters, according to their total carbon numbers. The total carbon and double-bond numbers of mycolic acids at each peak on gas chromatograms were determined from the [M]+, [M - 15]+, and [M - 90]+ ions on the mass spectrum, and straight and branched chain structures were identified by the mass fragment ions [A]+, due to C2--C3 cleavage [R-CH-O-Si(CH3)3]+, and [B]+, due to C3--C4 cleavage [(CH3)3-Si-O-CH-CH(R')-COOCH3]+. The concentration of odd- and even-carbon-numbered mycolic acids, which often overlap each other on gas chromatograms, and the composition of three homologous mycolic acids with different alpha units (C22:0, C24:0, and C26:0) were clearly determined by mass chromatography monitoring [M - 15]+ ions and [B - 29]+ ions, respectively. The molecular species composition of alpha-mycolic acids and their average carbon numbers (av. cn.) as a simple expression of the composition were calculated from the mass chromatograms. Each mycobacterial species examined was demonstrated to possess a characteristic profile of alpha-mycolic acid composition, and based on this the species were classified approximately into eight groups: C68 to C76 (av. cn. 72), dienoic, possessing a C20 alkyl branch at the 2 position (C22 alpha-unit) for Mycobacterium diernhoferi and Mycobacterium sp. strain 3707, a chromogenic rapid grower; C72 to C78 (av. cn. 75), dienoic with both C22 and C24 alpha units, containing a small or a large amount of odd-carbon-numbered molecules, for M. vaccae, M. rhodesiae, and M. phlei (chromogenic rapid growers); C72 to C80 (av. cn. 75 to 77), dienoic with C24 alpha-unit, containing a moderate or a large amount of odd-carbon-numbered molecules, for M. smegmatis, M. chitae, M. chelonae (M. chelonei), and M. fortuitum (nonchromogenic rapid growers); C78 to C82 (av. cn. 80), even-carbon-numbered dienoic with C24 alpha unit for M. agri and M. thermoresistible (rapid growers); C75 to C81 (av. cn. 77 to 79), odd-carbon-numbered dienoic with C24 alpha unit for M. nonchromogenicum complex (M. nonchromogenicum, M. terrae, and "M. novum") (slow growers); (vi) C76 to C84 (av. cn. 79 to 81), even-carbon-numbered dienoic with C24 alpha unit for MAIS complex including M. scrofulaceum, M. avium, and M. intracellulare (slow growers); (vii) C72 to C80 (av. cn. 77 to 79), even-carbon-numbered dienoic with C24 alpha unit for M. szulgai, M. gordonae, and M. kansasii (chromogenic slow growers); and (viii) C76 to C86 (av. cn. 79 to 81), even-carbon-numbered dienoic with C26 alpha unit M. bovis Ravenol and BCG and M. tuberculosis H37Rv. This study demonstrated that gas chromatography-mass spectrometric analysis of the molecular species composition of alpha-mycolic acid can give rapid, important, and very precise information for the identification of pathogenic and nonpathogenic mycobacterial species.
采用气相色谱法、气相色谱 - 质谱联用法和质量色谱法,测定了13种快速生长型和12种缓慢生长型分枝杆菌中碳数范围为C68至C86的α - 霉菌酸的分子种类组成。在气相色谱分析中,α - 霉菌酸的分子种类作为甲酯的三甲基硅醚衍生物,根据其总碳数得到了很好的分离。通过质谱图上的[M]+、[M - 15]+和[M - 90]+离子,测定了气相色谱图上各峰处霉菌酸的总碳数和双键数,并通过质量碎片离子[A]+(由于C2 - C3裂解[R - CH - O - Si(CH3)3]+)和[B]+(由于C3 - C4裂解[(CH3)3 - Si - O - CH - CH(R') - COOCH3]+)鉴定了直链和支链结构。通过质量色谱监测[M - 15]+离子和[B - 29]+离子,分别清晰地测定了气相色谱图上经常相互重叠的奇数和偶数碳数霉菌酸的浓度,以及三种具有不同α单元(C22:0、C24:0和C26:0)的同源霉菌酸的组成。根据质量色谱图计算了α - 霉菌酸的分子种类组成及其平均碳数(av. cn.),作为组成的一种简单表达方式。所检测的每种分枝杆菌都具有独特的α - 霉菌酸组成谱,基于此,这些菌种大致可分为八组:C68至C76(av. cn. 72),二烯酸型,在2位具有C20烷基支链(C22α单元),属于迪尔恩霍费尔分枝杆菌和分枝杆菌属菌株3707(一种产色快速生长菌);C72至C78(av. cn. 75),具有C22和C24α单元的二烯酸型,含有少量或大量奇数碳数分子,属于母牛分枝杆菌、罗得西亚分枝杆菌和草分枝杆菌(产色快速生长菌);C72至C80(av. cn. 75至77),具有C24α单元的二烯酸型,含有中等量或大量奇数碳数分子,属于耻垢分枝杆菌、契塔分枝杆菌、龟分枝杆菌(龟分枝杆菌)和偶然分枝杆菌(非产色快速生长菌);C78至C82(av. cn. 80),具有C24α单元的偶数碳数二烯酸型,属于农业分枝杆菌和耐热分枝杆菌(快速生长菌);C75至C81(av. cn. 77至79),具有C24α单元的奇数碳数二烯酸型,属于非产色分枝杆菌复合体(非产色分枝杆菌、地分枝杆菌和“新分枝杆菌”)(缓慢生长菌);(vi)C76至C84(av. cn. 79至81),具有C24α单元的偶数碳数二烯酸型,属于包括瘰疬分枝杆菌、鸟分枝杆菌和胞内分枝杆菌在内的MAIS复合体(缓慢生长菌);(vii)C72至C80(av. cn. 77至79),具有C24α单元的偶数碳数二烯酸型,属于苏尔加分枝杆菌、戈登分枝杆菌和堪萨斯分枝杆菌(产色缓慢生长菌);以及(viii)C76至C86(av. cn. 79至81),具有C26α单元的偶数碳数二烯酸型,属于牛分枝杆菌拉韦诺尔株和卡介苗以及结核分枝杆菌H37Rv。本研究表明,对α - 霉菌酸分子种类组成进行气相色谱 - 质谱分析可为鉴定致病性和非致病性分枝杆菌提供快速、重要且非常精确的信息。