Law School & Intellectual Property School, Jinan University, Guangzhou, China.
Faculty of Law, University of Macau, Taipa, Macau, China.
Front Public Health. 2023 Sep 29;11:1208615. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2023.1208615. eCollection 2023.
This study investigates the challenges that China's health code system presents to individuals' lives and social development, using normative analysis and a case study. It looks for effective strategies to reform and regulate this system to prepare for future pandemics. Health code apps and mini programs have been widely deployed as effective tools for COVID-19 containment in China. However, their widespread and improper use has created risks due to the lack of both a systematic design and a basic supervision mechanism. The health code system risks infringing on individual privacy during data collection and storage. During the pandemic, the right to liberty and the right to treatment of Chinese citizens who lacked an appropriate health code were severely compromised. In some instances, the health code system was used as a stability maintenance tool by the authorities through arbitrary health code conversions. This article argues that China's health code systems should be reformed and regulated in preparation for future pandemics and that a new act regulating its management and use should be launched at the national level. Data collection, retention, and processing should be limited to the minimum amount of data needed to achieve the objective of protecting public health. The health code conversion power wielded by the authorities should be defined and regulated, the rules and procedures of code conversion should be transparent, arbitrary health code conversion behaviors should be prevented and punished, and persons whose rights have been violated by wrongful code conversion should have access to legal remedies.
本研究采用规范分析和案例研究的方法,探讨了中国健康码系统给个人生活和社会发展带来的挑战,寻求有效的改革和监管策略,为未来的大流行做好准备。健康码应用程序和小程序已被广泛用作中国控制新冠疫情的有效工具。然而,由于缺乏系统设计和基本监管机制,它们的广泛和不当使用带来了风险。健康码系统在数据收集和存储过程中存在侵犯个人隐私的风险。在疫情期间,缺乏适当健康码的中国公民的自由权和治疗权受到严重侵犯。在某些情况下,健康码系统被当局用作稳定维护工具,通过任意的健康码转换来实现。本文认为,中国的健康码系统应进行改革和监管,为未来的大流行做好准备,并应在国家层面推出一项新的管理和使用法规。数据收集、保留和处理应限于保护公众健康目标所需的最小数据量。应明确和规范当局行使的健康码转换权力,代码转换的规则和程序应透明,防止和惩罚任意的健康码转换行为,因错误的代码转换而权利受到侵犯的人应能获得法律救济。