School of Public Health, Makerere University College of Health Sciences, Kampala, Uganda.
Health Support Initiatives, Kampala, Uganda.
PLoS One. 2023 Oct 19;18(10):e0292053. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0292053. eCollection 2023.
Uganda, like many other developing countries, faces the challenges of unreliable estimates for its immunization target population. Strengthening immunization data quality and its use for improving immunization program performance are critical steps toward improving coverage and equity of immunization programs. The goal of this study was to determine the effectiveness of using community health workers (CHWs) to obtain quality and reliable data that can be used for planning and evidence-based response actions.
An implementation study in which 5 health facilities were stratified and randomized in two groups to (i) receive a package of interventions including monthly health unit immunization data audit meetings, and defaulter tracking and linkage and (ii) to serve as a control group was conducted between July and September 2020. Immunization coverage of infants in both arms was determined by a review of records three months before and after the study interventions. In addition, key informant and in-depth interviews were conducted among facility-based health workers and CHWs respectively, at the endline to explore the feasibility of the interventions.
Overall, a total of 2,048 children under one year eligible for immunization were registered in Bukabooli sub-county by CHWs as compared to the estimated district population of 1,889 children representing a moderate variance of 8.4%. The study further showed that it is feasible to use CHWs to track and link defaulters to points of immunization services as more than two-thirds (68%) of the children defaulting returned for catch-up immunization services. At the endline, immunization coverage for the Oral Polio Vaccine third dose; Rotavirus vaccine second dose; Pneumococcal Conjugate Vaccine third dose increased in both the intervention and control health facilities. There was a decrease in coverage for the Measles-Rubella vaccine decreased in the intervention health facilities and a decrease in Bacillus Calmette-Guérin vaccine coverage in the control facilities. Difference in difference analysis demonstrated that the intervention caused a significant 35.1% increase in coverage of Bacillus Calmette-Guérin vaccine (CI 9.00-61.19; p<0.05)). The intervention facilities had a 17.9% increase in DTP3 coverage compared to the control facilities (CI: 1.69-34.1) while for MR, OPV3, and Rota2 antigens, there was no significant effect of the intervention.
The use of CHWs to obtain reliable population estimates is feasible and can be useful in areas with consistently poor immunization coverage to estimate the target population. Facilitating monthly health unit immunization data audit meetings to identify, track, and link defaulters to immunization services is effective in increasing immunization coverage and equity.
乌干达与许多其他发展中国家一样,面临着免疫目标人群估计不可靠的挑战。加强免疫数据质量及其在改善免疫规划绩效方面的使用,是提高免疫规划覆盖范围和公平性的关键步骤。本研究的目的是确定利用社区卫生工作者(CHWs)获取可用于规划和循证应对措施的高质量和可靠数据的效果。
在 2020 年 7 月至 9 月期间,进行了一项实施研究,将 5 个卫生机构分为两组进行分层随机分组,(i)接受一揽子干预措施,包括每月的卫生单位免疫数据审计会议以及失访者跟踪和联系,(ii)作为对照组。在研究干预措施前后三个月,通过审查记录确定婴儿的免疫覆盖率。此外,在研究结束时,分别对机构内卫生工作者和 CHW 进行了关键知情人访谈和深入访谈,以探讨干预措施的可行性。
总体而言,Bukabooli 分区的 CHW 共登记了 2048 名一岁以下有资格接受免疫接种的儿童,而区估计人口为 1889 名儿童,这表明存在中度偏差,为 8.4%。研究还表明,利用 CHW 跟踪和联系失访者以获得免疫服务点是可行的,因为超过三分之二(68%)的失访儿童返回接受补种免疫服务。在研究结束时,口服脊髓灰质炎疫苗第三剂;轮状病毒疫苗第二剂;肺炎球菌结合疫苗第三剂的免疫覆盖率在干预和对照卫生机构中均有所增加。干预卫生机构的麻疹-风疹疫苗覆盖率下降,对照卫生机构的卡介苗疫苗覆盖率下降。差异分析表明,干预措施导致卡介苗疫苗覆盖率显著增加 35.1%(CI 9.00-61.19;p<0.05)。与对照设施相比,干预设施的 DTP3 覆盖率增加了 17.9%(CI:1.69-34.1),而对于 MR、OPV3 和 Rota2 抗原,干预没有显著效果。
利用 CHW 获得可靠的人口估计是可行的,并且在免疫覆盖率持续较差的地区,对于估计目标人群是有用的。促进每月的卫生单位免疫数据审计会议,以识别、跟踪和联系失访者以获得免疫服务,可有效提高免疫覆盖率和公平性。