Department of Urology, North Academic Hospital, AP-HM, Marseille, France.
Medical Information and Data Department, Programme de Médicalisation des Systèmes d'Informations, Ramsay Santé, Paris, France.
Eur Urol Oncol. 2024 Jun;7(3):316-318. doi: 10.1016/j.euo.2023.10.006. Epub 2023 Oct 19.
Radical prostatectomy (RP) can be performed using an open (ORP), laparoscopic (LRP) or robotic (RARP) approach. Most studies, even in experienced centers, have not provided solid evidence demonstrating better outcomes when using the robotic approach. In addition, one of the remaining concerns about RARP is its cost effectiveness, leading to no reimbursement for this surgical technique in some countries and thus health care inequality. We used data from a French national registry to improve knowledge of RP outcomes in a real-world scenario in order to guide and inform health care decision-makers. A total of 21 213 RP procedures were performed in 645 French centers in 2021 (ORP 20%, LRP 25%, and RARP 55% of cases). ORP was associated with longer hospital stay (p < 0.001), higher rates of postoperative complications (p < 0.001), fewer days out of hospital within 90 d of surgery (81.7 vs 83.6 vs 84.9 d for ORP vs LRP vs RARP; p < 0.00), and higher hospitalization costs (€2424 vs €1789 vs €1302). RARP is an optimal and cost-effective approach, with several advantages over ORP. Our data can be used by health care decision-makers to facilitate access to and reimbursement for the robotic approach for RP indications. PATIENT SUMMARY: For men with prostate cancer for whom surgery is recommended, surgeons can remove the prostate using open surgery or a keyhole approach with or without robot assistance. Open surgery has higher costs, more complications, and longer hospital stays.
根治性前列腺切除术 (RP) 可采用开放式 (ORP)、腹腔镜 (LRP) 或机器人 (RARP) 方法进行。即使在经验丰富的中心,大多数研究也未能提供确凿证据表明机器人方法的效果更好。此外,关于 RARP 的一个遗留问题是其成本效益,这导致在一些国家该手术技术无法获得报销,从而导致医疗保健不平等。我们使用来自法国国家登记处的数据,旨在提高对真实世界中 RP 结果的认识,以便为医疗保健决策者提供指导和信息。2021 年,645 家法国中心共进行了 21213 例 RP 手术(ORP 占 20%,LRP 占 25%,RARP 占 55%)。ORP 与住院时间延长(p<0.001)、术后并发症发生率较高(p<0.001)、术后 90 天内出院天数较少(ORP 为 81.7 天,LRP 为 83.6 天,RARP 为 84.9 天;p<0.00)以及住院费用较高(2424 欧元 vs 1789 欧元 vs 1302 欧元)相关。RARP 是一种优化且具有成本效益的方法,与 ORP 相比具有多项优势。我们的数据可被医疗保健决策者用于促进 RP 适应证机器人方法的使用和报销。
对于建议进行手术的前列腺癌男性患者,外科医生可以通过开放性手术或微创(钥匙孔)手术切除前列腺,这些手术可以选择使用机器人辅助或不使用机器人辅助。开放性手术的成本更高、并发症更多且住院时间更长。