Ollroge Rasmus
Freie Universität Berlin, Cluster of Excellence "Contestations of the Liberal Script (SCRIPTS)", Berlin, Germany.
Br J Sociol. 2023 Dec;74(5):873-914. doi: 10.1111/1468-4446.13060. Epub 2023 Oct 22.
Does globalization increase polarization in attitudes toward international trade, immigration, and international organizations? Research from a variety of fields and disciplines assumes this relationship, but empirical studies are few. In this study, I examine whether globalization increases the attitudinal divide between education groups, with education being one of the main characteristics of social stratification distinguishing winners from losers of globalization. I use data from three waves of the National Identity Module of the International Social Survey Programme (ISSP) from 1995 to 2013 covering 29 countries (n = 79,101) to analyze between- and within-country interactions between the level of globalization and education in explaining attitudes toward globalization. The results show that while the attitudinal divide between educational groups is larger in countries with higher levels of globalization (between effect), polarization decreases as the level of globalization increases within countries (within effect), as persons with lower and medium levels of education become more positive toward globalization under increasing levels of globalization. The results are consistent across a wide range of robustness checks, including controlling for occupational class as a further distinction between winners and losers of globalization. The findings suggest that the expectations about a widening attitudinal divide between winners and losers of globalization should be treated with more caution.
全球化是否会加剧人们在国际贸易、移民和国际组织态度上的两极分化?来自各个领域和学科的研究都假定存在这种关系,但实证研究却很少。在本研究中,我考察全球化是否会加剧不同教育群体之间的态度分歧,教育是社会分层的主要特征之一,它区分了全球化的赢家和输家。我使用了国际社会调查项目(ISSP)1995年至2013年三轮国民身份模块的数据,涵盖29个国家(n = 79,101),以分析全球化水平与教育在解释对全球化态度方面的国家间和国家内部的相互作用。结果表明,虽然在全球化水平较高的国家中,教育群体之间的态度分歧更大(国家间效应),但在国家内部,随着全球化水平的提高,两极分化会减少(国家内部效应),因为随着全球化水平的提高,中低教育水平的人对全球化的态度变得更加积极。在包括将职业阶层作为全球化赢家和输家的进一步区分进行控制在内的广泛稳健性检验中,结果都是一致的。研究结果表明,对于全球化赢家和输家之间态度分歧会扩大的预期应更加谨慎对待。