Tong Xiaoyu, Fang Xin, Wang Shigeng, Fan Yong, Wei Wei, Xiao Qingzhu, Chen Anliang, Liu Yijun, Liu Lei
Department of Radiology, First Affiliated Hospital of Dalian Medical University, Dalian, China.
School of Investment and Project Management, Dongbei University of Finance and Economics, Dalian, China.
Quant Imaging Med Surg. 2023 Oct 1;13(10):6571-6582. doi: 10.21037/qims-23-748. Epub 2023 Sep 13.
The early detection and treatment of osteoporosis can help prevent osteoporosis-related fractures, especially in patients who undergo enhanced computed tomography (CT) scans for disease diagnosis or evaluation of treatment outcomes. Although Hounsfield unit (HU) measurement of the vertebral body has been shown to have a strong positive correlation with bone mineral density (BMD), the contrast media will impact the CT value of the vertebral body and decrease the accuracy. This study is aimed to examine the distinctions in vertebral body CT attenuation measurement on true unenhanced (TUE) and virtual unenhanced (VUE) images generated from triphasic enhanced dual-energy CT (DECT) scans and to determine the feasibility of assessing BMD and detecting osteoporosis on VUE images as compared to quantitative CT (QCT).
A total of 235 patients underwent abdominal CT examinations that included unenhanced (with 120 kVp and Smart mA) and triphasic enhanced DECT scans. The BMD and CT attenuation values of the L1-L2 vertebrae were measured on TUE and VUE images reconstructed from the triphasic enhanced CT. The differences and associations between TUE and VUE generated from triphasic enhanced CT were analyzed. The diagnostic performances of HU measurements obtained from TUE and VUE images were evaluated using receiver operating characteristic curve.
The BMD and HU measurements of the vertebrae showed good interobserver repeatability on both TUE and VUE images (all intercorrelation coefficients >0.92). The CT attenuation values of L1 and L2 and their average value showed no statistically significant difference among the triphasic VUE images (F=0.121, F=0.061, F=0.090; all P values >0.05) but were significantly lower than those obtained from the TUE images. HU measurements in both the TUE and triphasic VUE images, along with the reference BMD derived from QCT, demonstrated a strong positive correlation (r =0.981, r =0.966, r =0.962, r =0.964; all P values <0.05), with excellent diagnostic performance for the diagnoses of osteoporosis and osteopenia (all areas under curve >0.95). The Bland-Altman scatter plot exhibited good agreement, as the deviations between the reference BMD and the calculated BMD were evenly distributed around 0.
Although the attenuation values of the vertebrae on the VUE images were underestimated compared to those on the TUE images, the HU measurement on VUE image was effective in assessing BMD and detecting osteoporosis and osteopenia with good diagnostic performance.
骨质疏松症的早期检测和治疗有助于预防与骨质疏松症相关的骨折,尤其是对于那些接受增强计算机断层扫描(CT)以进行疾病诊断或评估治疗效果的患者。尽管已证明椎体的亨氏单位(HU)测量值与骨密度(BMD)呈强正相关,但造影剂会影响椎体的CT值并降低准确性。本研究旨在探讨三相增强双能CT(DECT)扫描生成的真实平扫(TUE)和虚拟平扫(VUE)图像上椎体CT衰减测量的差异,并确定与定量CT(QCT)相比,在VUE图像上评估BMD和检测骨质疏松症的可行性。
共有235例患者接受了腹部CT检查,包括平扫(120 kVp和智能毫安)和三相增强DECT扫描。在从三相增强CT重建的TUE和VUE图像上测量L1-L2椎体的BMD和CT衰减值。分析三相增强CT生成的TUE和VUE之间的差异和相关性。使用受试者工作特征曲线评估从TUE和VUE图像获得的HU测量值的诊断性能。
椎体的BMD和HU测量值在TUE和VUE图像上均显示出良好的观察者间重复性(所有组内相关系数>0.92)。三相VUE图像上L1和L2的CT衰减值及其平均值之间无统计学显著差异(F=0.121,F=0.061,F=0.090;所有P值>0.05),但均显著低于从TUE图像获得的值。TUE和三相VUE图像中的HU测量值,以及源自QCT的参考BMD,均显示出强正相关(r =0.981,r =0.966,r =0.962,r =0.964;所有P值<0.05),对骨质疏松症和骨质减少症的诊断具有出色的诊断性能(所有曲线下面积>0.95)。Bland-Altman散点图显示出良好的一致性,因为参考BMD与计算出的BMD之间的偏差均匀分布在0左右。
尽管VUE图像上椎体的衰减值与TUE图像相比被低估,但VUE图像上的HU测量在评估BMD以及检测骨质疏松症和骨质减少症方面是有效的,具有良好的诊断性能。