Stewart Matthew P, Ohno Paul E, McKinney Karena, Martin Scot T
School of Engineering and Applied Sciences, Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02138, United States.
Department of Chemistry, Colby College, Waterville, Maine 04901, United States.
ACS Earth Space Chem. 2023 Oct 4;7(10):1956-1970. doi: 10.1021/acsearthspacechem.3c00054. eCollection 2023 Oct 19.
Photoionization detectors (PIDs) are lightweight and respond in real time to the concentrations of volatile organic compounds (VOCs), making them suitable for environmental measurements on many platforms. However, the nonselective sensing mechanism of PIDs challenges data interpretation, particularly when exposed to the complex VOC mixtures prevalent in the Earth's atmosphere. Herein, two approaches to this challenge are investigated. In the first, quantum-chemistry calculations are used to estimate photoionization cross sections and ionization potentials of individual species. In the second, machine learning models are trained on these calculated values, as well as empirical PID response factors, and then used for prediction. For both approaches, the resulting information for individual species is used to model the overall PID response to a complex VOC mixture. In complement, laboratory experiments in the Harvard Environmental Chamber are carried out to measure the PID response to the complex molecular mixture produced by α-pinene oxidation under various conditions. The observations show that the measured PID response is 15% to 30% smaller than the PID response modeled by quantum-chemistry calculations of the photoionization cross section for the photo-oxidation experiments and 15% to 20% for the ozonolysis experiments. By comparison, the measured PID response is captured within a 95% confidence interval by the use of machine learning to model the PID response based on the empirical response factor in all experiments. Taken together, the results of this study demonstrate the application of machine learning to augment the performance of a nonselective chemical sensor. The approach can be generalized to other reactive species, oxidants, and reaction mechanisms, thus enhancing the utility and interpretability of PID measurements for studying atmospheric VOCs.
光离子化探测器(PIDs)重量轻,能实时响应挥发性有机化合物(VOCs)的浓度,使其适用于多种平台的环境测量。然而,PIDs的非选择性传感机制对数据解读提出了挑战,尤其是当暴露于地球大气中普遍存在的复杂VOC混合物时。本文研究了应对这一挑战的两种方法。第一种方法是使用量子化学计算来估计单个物种的光离子化截面和电离电位。第二种方法是基于这些计算值以及经验PID响应因子训练机器学习模型,然后用于预测。对于这两种方法,单个物种的所得信息都用于模拟PIDs对复杂VOC混合物的整体响应。作为补充,在哈佛环境舱中进行了实验室实验,以测量在各种条件下PIDs对α-蒎烯氧化产生的复杂分子混合物的响应。观察结果表明,在光氧化实验中,测量到的PID响应比通过光离子化截面的量子化学计算模拟的PID响应小15%至30%,在臭氧分解实验中则小15%至20%。相比之下,在所有实验中,通过使用机器学习基于经验响应因子对PID响应进行建模,测量到的PID响应被捕获在95%的置信区间内。综上所述,本研究结果证明了机器学习在增强非选择性化学传感器性能方面的应用。该方法可推广到其他反应物种、氧化剂和反应机制,从而提高PID测量在研究大气VOCs方面的实用性和可解释性。