Castle Alison C, Hoeppner Susanne S, Manne-Goehler Jennifer M, Olivier Stephen, Magodoro Itai M, Singh Urisha, Edwards Johnathan A, Tanser Frank, Bassett Ingrid V, Wong Emily B, Siedner Mark J
Africa Health Research Institute, KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa.
Division of Infectious Diseases, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts, United States of America.
PLOS Glob Public Health. 2023 Oct 27;3(10):e0001698. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgph.0001698. eCollection 2023.
Valid screening and diagnostic algorithms are needed to achieve 2030 targets proposed by the WHO's Global Diabetes Compact. We explored anthropometric thresholds to optimally screen and refer individuals for diabetes testing in rural South Africa. We evaluated screening thresholds for waist circumference (WC), body mass index (BMI), and waist-hip ratio (WHR) to detect dysglycemia based on a glycated hemoglobin (HbA1C) ≥6.5% among adults in a population-based study in South Africa using weighted, non-parametric ROC regression analyses. We then assessed the diagnostic validity of traditional obesity thresholds, explored optimal thresholds for this population, and fit models stratified by sex, age, and HIV status. The prevalence of dysglycemia in the total study population (n = 17,846) was 7.7%. WC had greater discriminatory capacity than WHR to detect dysglycemia in men (p-value<0.001) and women (p<0.001). WC had greater discriminatory capacity than BMI to detect dysglycemia in women (p<0.001). However, BMI and WC performed similarly for men (p = 0.589). Whereas traditional WC thresholds for women (>81cm) performed well (sensitivity 91%, positive predictive value [PPV] 14.9%), substantially lower thresholds were needed to achieve acceptable sensitivity and PPV among men (traditional >94cm, derived >79.5cm). WC outperforms BMI as an anthropometric screening measure for dysglycemia in rural South Africa. Whereas WC guideline thresholds are appropriate for women, male-derived WC cutoffs performed better at lower thresholds. In this rural South African population, thresholds that maximize specificity and PPV for efficient resource allocation may be preferred.
需要有效的筛查和诊断算法来实现世界卫生组织全球糖尿病契约提出的2030年目标。我们探索了人体测量阈值,以在南非农村地区对个体进行最佳筛查并转诊其进行糖尿病检测。在南非一项基于人群的研究中,我们使用加权非参数ROC回归分析,评估了腰围(WC)、体重指数(BMI)和腰臀比(WHR)的筛查阈值,以检测糖化血红蛋白(HbA1C)≥6.5%的血糖异常情况。然后,我们评估了传统肥胖阈值的诊断有效性,探索了该人群的最佳阈值,并建立了按性别、年龄和HIV状态分层的模型。总研究人群(n = 17,846)中血糖异常的患病率为7.7%。在男性(p值<0.001)和女性(p<0.001)中,WC检测血糖异常的鉴别能力高于WHR。在女性中,WC检测血糖异常的鉴别能力高于BMI(p<0.001)。然而,BMI和WC在男性中的表现相似(p = 0.589)。传统的女性WC阈值(>81cm)表现良好(敏感性91%,阳性预测值[PPV] 14.9%),但在男性中需要更低得多的阈值才能达到可接受的敏感性和PPV(传统阈值>94cm,推导阈值>79.5cm)。在南非农村地区,作为血糖异常的人体测量筛查指标,WC优于BMI。虽然WC指南阈值适用于女性,但男性推导的WC临界值在较低阈值时表现更好。在这个南非农村人群中,可能更倾向于选择能使特异性和PPV最大化以有效分配资源的阈值。