Department of Physical Therapy, School of Health Science, International University of Health and Welfare, Ohtawara, Japan.
Department of Rehabilitation, International University of Health and Welfare Mita Hospital, Tokyo, Japan.
J Back Musculoskelet Rehabil. 2024;37(2):427-435. doi: 10.3233/BMR-230127.
Elastic taping that applies shear force affects joint movement. However, it remains uncertain whether elastic taping or stretching is more effective in improving flexibility.
We investigated whether elastic taping for flexibility improvement is comparable to traditional stretching.
In this randomized controlled trial, 64 university students were randomly allocated to two groups: elastic taping on the sole or 30 s of static stretching. The primary outcome measures were the straight leg raising angle, tested with an equivalence margin (± 9.61∘ on changes), and the fingertip-to-floor distance. Secondary outcomes were the hip flexor and knee extensor strength, two-step distance, adverse events, and pain intensity during the intervention, which were compared using conventional statistical methods.
The mean differences in straight leg raising between the two groups after the interventions were not greater than the equivalence margin (mean [95% CI]: 1.4 [-6.9, 9.5]; equivalence margin, -9.61∘ to 9.61∘). There were no consistent differences between groups in terms of secondary outcomes except for pain intensity during the intervention (p> 0.05). Elastic taping did not induce pain.
Elastic taping augments the flexibility-improving effect comparable to static stretching, based on an equivalence margin. Elastic taping of the sole appears to be an alternative method of improving flexibility.
应用切变力的弹性绷带会影响关节运动。然而,弹性绷带是否比传统拉伸更能有效提高柔韧性仍不确定。
我们研究了弹性绷带是否能与传统拉伸一样提高柔韧性。
在这项随机对照试验中,64 名大学生被随机分配到两组:脚底弹性绷带或 30 秒静态拉伸。主要结局指标为直腿抬高角度,用等效边界(变化的±9.61∘)和指尖到地板的距离进行测试。次要结局指标为髋关节屈肌和膝关节伸肌力量、两步距离、干预期间的不良事件和疼痛强度,采用常规统计方法进行比较。
干预后两组直腿抬高角度的平均差异不大于等效边界(平均[95%CI]:1.4[-6.9, 9.5];等效边界,-9.61∘至 9.61∘)。除干预期间的疼痛强度外(p>0.05),两组之间在次要结局方面没有一致的差异。弹性绷带不会引起疼痛。
基于等效边界,弹性绷带增强了与静态拉伸相当的柔韧性改善效果。脚底弹性绷带似乎是提高柔韧性的一种替代方法。