Bellan Valeria, Braithwaite Felicity A, Wilkinson Erica M, Stanton Tasha R, Moseley G Lorimer
Cognitive and Systems Neuroscience Research Hub (CSN-RH), University of South Australia, Adelaide, South Australia, Australia.
IIMPACT in Health, University of South Australia, Adelaide, South Australia, Australia.
PeerJ. 2021 Aug 20;9:e11882. doi: 10.7717/peerj.11882. eCollection 2021.
Anecdotally, people living with Complex Regional Pain Syndrome (CRPS) often report difficulties in localising their own affected limb when it is out of view. Experimental attempts to investigate this report have used explicit tasks and yielded varied results.
Here we used a limb localisation task that interrogates implicit mechanisms because we first induce a compelling illusion called the Disappearing Hand Trick (DHT). In the DHT, participants judge their hands to be close together when, in fact, they are far apart. Sixteen volunteers with unilateral upper limb CRPS (mean age 39 ± 12 years, four males), 15 volunteers with non-CRPS persistent hand pain ('pain controls'; mean age 58 ± 13 years, two males) and 29 pain-free volunteers ('pain-free controls'; mean age 36 ± 19 years, 10 males) performed a hand-localisation task after each of three conditions: the DHT illusion and two control conditions in which no illusion was performed. The conditions were repeated twice (one for each hand). We hypothesised that (1) participants with CRPS would perform worse at hand self-localisation than both the control samples; (2) participants with non-CRPS persistent hand pain would perform worse than pain-free controls; (3) participants in both persistent pain groups would perform worse with their affected hand than with their unaffected hand.
Our first two hypotheses were not supported. Our third hypothesis was supported -when visually and proprioceptively encoded positions of the hands were incongruent (. after the DHT), relocalisation performance was worse with the affected hand than it was with the unaffected hand. The similar results in hand localisation in the control and pain groups might suggest that, when implicit processes are required, people with CRPS' ability to localise their limb is preserved.
据传闻,患有复杂性区域疼痛综合征(CRPS)的人在看不到自己受影响肢体时,常常报告难以定位该肢体。为调查这一报告所做的实验尝试使用了明确的任务,结果各不相同。
在此,我们使用了一项肢体定位任务来探究隐性机制,因为我们首先诱发了一种名为“消失的手错觉”(DHT)的强烈错觉。在DHT中,参与者会判断他们的手靠得很近,而实际上它们相距很远。16名单侧上肢患有CRPS的志愿者(平均年龄39±12岁,4名男性)、15名患有非CRPS持续性手部疼痛的志愿者(“疼痛对照组”;平均年龄58±13岁,2名男性)和29名无疼痛的志愿者(“无疼痛对照组”;平均年龄36±19岁,10名男性)在三种情况中的每一种之后进行手部定位任务:DHT错觉以及两种未产生错觉的对照情况。这些情况重复两次(每只手各一次)。我们假设:(1)患有CRPS的参与者在手部自我定位方面的表现会比两个对照组样本都差;(2)患有非CRPS持续性手部疼痛的参与者表现会比无疼痛对照组差;(3)两个持续性疼痛组的参与者用受影响的手进行定位的表现会比用未受影响的手差。
我们的前两个假设未得到支持。我们的第三个假设得到了支持——当手部的视觉编码位置和本体感觉编码位置不一致时(即在DHT之后),受影响的手重新定位的表现比未受影响的手更差。对照组和疼痛组在手部定位方面的相似结果可能表明,当需要隐性过程时,患有CRPS 的人的肢体定位能力得以保留。