San Diego State University/UC San Diego Joint Doctoral Program in Clinical Psychology, San Diego, California.
VA San Diego Healthcare System, San Diego, California; Department of Psychiatry, University of California, San Diego, California.
J Pain. 2024 Apr;25(4):862-874. doi: 10.1016/j.jpain.2023.10.021. Epub 2023 Oct 31.
Chronic pain (CP) is a debilitating and increasingly common health condition that adversely impacts function, including physical activity (PA). Research using ambulatory assessment (AA) methods (eg, ecological momentary assessment, actigraphy) offers promise for elucidating the relationship between momentary pain and objective PA in CP populations. This study aimed to systematically review articles assessing the association between momentary pain and PA in adults with CP as measured using AA and to make recommendations for the measurement and study of this relationship. Five databases were systematically searched, and 13 unique records (N = 768) met the inclusion criteria. CP conditions included mixed/nonspecific CP (k = 3), low back pain (k = 2), fibromyalgia (k = 1), unspecified arthritis (k = 1), and hip/knee osteoarthritis (k = 6). The average age of participants across studies was 55.29 years, and the majority identified as women (60.68%) and White (83.16%). All studies measured objective PA via actigraphy, and momentary pain with either a diary/log or ratings on an actigraph. Studies varied in the quantification of PA (ie, activity counts, step count, moderate-vigorous PA), statistical method (ie, correlation, regression, multilevel modeling), and inclusion of moderators (eg, pain acceptance). Studies reported mixed results for the pain-PA relationship. This heterogeneity suggests that no summarizing conclusions can be drawn about the pain-PA relationship without further investigation into its complex nuances. More within-person and exploratory examinations that maximize the richness of AA data are needed. A greater understanding of this relationship can inform psychotherapeutic and behavioral recommendations to improve CP outcomes. PERSPECTIVE: This article presents a systematic review of the literature on the association between momentary pain and PA in adults with CP as measured using AA methods. A better understanding of this nuanced relationship could help elucidate areas for timely intervention and may inform clinical recommendations to improve CP outcomes. PROSPERO REGISTRATION NUMBER: CRD42023389913.
慢性疼痛(CP)是一种使人虚弱且日益常见的健康状况,会对功能产生不利影响,包括身体活动(PA)。使用动态评估(AA)方法(例如,生态瞬时评估、活动记录仪)的研究为阐明 CP 人群中瞬时疼痛与客观 PA 之间的关系提供了希望。本研究旨在系统地回顾评估使用 AA 测量的 CP 成人中瞬时疼痛与 PA 之间关系的文章,并为该关系的测量和研究提出建议。系统地检索了五个数据库,有 13 份独特的记录(N=768)符合纳入标准。CP 疾病包括混合/非特异性 CP(k=3)、下腰痛(k=2)、纤维肌痛(k=1)、未特指关节炎(k=1)和髋/膝骨关节炎(k=6)。研究中参与者的平均年龄为 55.29 岁,大多数为女性(60.68%)和白人(83.16%)。所有研究均通过活动记录仪测量客观 PA,通过日记/日志或活动记录仪上的评分测量瞬时疼痛。研究在 PA 的量化(即活动计数、步数、中高强度 PA)、统计方法(即相关性、回归、多层次建模)和纳入调节因素(例如,疼痛接受)方面存在差异。研究报告了疼痛与 PA 关系的混合结果。这种异质性表明,如果不进一步深入研究其复杂细微差别,就无法对疼痛与 PA 的关系得出总结性结论。需要进行更多的个体内和探索性检查,以最大限度地利用 AA 数据的丰富性。更好地了解这种关系可以为改善 CP 结果提供心理治疗和行为建议。观点:本文系统地回顾了使用 AA 方法测量的 CP 成人中瞬时疼痛与 PA 之间关系的文献。更好地理解这种微妙的关系可以帮助阐明及时干预的领域,并可能为改善 CP 结果提供临床建议。PROSPERO 注册号:CRD42023389913。