Liu Kai, Zhu Lixin, Wei Nian, Li Daoji
State Key Laboratory of Estuarine and Coastal Research, East China Normal University, 500 Dongchuan Road, Shanghai 200241, China.
State Key Laboratory of Estuarine and Coastal Research, East China Normal University, 500 Dongchuan Road, Shanghai 200241, China; Marine and Environmental Sciences, Northeastern University, 360 Huntington Avenue, Boston, MA 02115, USA.
J Hazard Mater. 2024 Feb 5;463:132897. doi: 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2023.132897. Epub 2023 Nov 2.
Long-term environmental loading of microplastics (MPs) causes alarming exposure risks for a variety of species worldwide, considered a planetary threat to the well-being of ecosystems. Robust quantitative estimates of MP extents and featured diversity are the basis for comprehending their environmental implications precisely, and of these methods, membrane-based characterizations predominate with respect to MP inspections. However, though crucial to filter-based MP quantification, aggregation statuses of retained MPs on these substrates remain poorly understood, leaving us a "blind box" that exaggerates uncertainty in quantitive strategies of preselected areas without knowing overview loading structure. To clarify this uncertainty and estimate their impacts on MP counting, using MP imaging data assembled from peer-reviewed studies through a systematic review, here we analyze the particle-specific profiles of MPs retained on various substrates according to their centre of mass with a fast-random forests algorithm. We visualize the formation of distinct galaxy-like MP aggregation-similar to the solar system and Milky Way System comprised of countless stars-across the pristine and environmental samples by leveraging two spatial parameters developed in this study. This unique pattern greatly challenges the homogeneously or randomly distributed MP presumption adopted extensively for simplified membrane-based quantification purposes and selective ROI (region of interest) estimates for smaller-sized plastics down to the nano-range, as well as the compatibility theory using pristine MPs as the standard to quantify the presence of environmental MPs. Furthermore, our evaluation with exemplified numeration cases confirms these location-specific and area-dependent biases in many imaging analyses of a selective filter area, ascribed to the minimum possibility of reaching an ideal turnover point for the selective quantitive strategies. Consequently, disproportionate MP schemes on loading substrates yield great uncertainty in their quantification processing, highlighting the prompt need to include pattern-resolved calibration prior to quantification. Our findings substantially advance our understanding of the structure, behavior, and formation of these MP aggregating statuses on filtering substrates, addressing a fundamental question puzzling scientists as to why reproducible MP quantification is barely achievable even for subsamples. This study inspires the following studies to reconsider the impacts of aggregating patterns on the effective counting protocols and target-specific removal of retained MP aggregates through membrane separation techniques.
长期的微塑料(MPs)环境负荷对全球各种物种构成了惊人的暴露风险,被视为对生态系统福祉的全球性威胁。对微塑料程度和特征多样性进行可靠的定量估计是精确理解其环境影响的基础,在这些方法中,基于膜的表征在微塑料检测方面占主导地位。然而,尽管对于基于过滤的微塑料定量至关重要,但这些基质上保留的微塑料的聚集状态仍知之甚少,给我们留下了一个“盲盒”,在不了解总体负荷结构的情况下,夸大了预选区域定量策略中的不确定性。为了澄清这种不确定性并估计它们对微塑料计数的影响,我们通过系统综述,利用从同行评审研究中收集的微塑料成像数据,在此使用快速随机森林算法根据其质心分析了保留在各种基质上的微塑料的颗粒特异性特征。通过利用本研究中开发的两个空间参数,我们可视化了在原始样本和环境样本中形成的独特的类似星系的微塑料聚集——类似于由无数恒星组成的太阳系和银河系。这种独特的模式极大地挑战了广泛采用的用于简化基于膜的定量目的以及对小至纳米范围的较小尺寸塑料进行选择性感兴趣区域(ROI)估计的均匀或随机分布的微塑料假设,以及使用原始微塑料作为标准来量化环境微塑料存在的兼容性理论。此外,我们通过示例计数案例进行的评估证实了在许多选择性过滤区域的成像分析中存在这些特定位置和面积依赖性偏差,这归因于选择性定量策略达到理想周转点的可能性最小。因此,加载基质上不成比例的微塑料方案在其定量处理中产生了很大的不确定性,突出了在定量之前迫切需要纳入模式解析校准的必要性。我们的发现极大地推进了我们对这些微塑料在过滤基质上的聚集状态的结构、行为和形成的理解,解决了一个困扰科学家的基本问题,即为什么即使对于子样本,可重复的微塑料定量也几乎无法实现。这项研究促使后续研究重新考虑聚集模式对有效计数协议的影响,以及通过膜分离技术对保留的微塑料聚集体进行目标特异性去除的问题。