Kerman Jared, Brewer Russell, Hotton Anna, Flores Rey, Devlin Samantha A, Friedman Eleanor E, Schneider John A, McNulty Moira C
Chicago Center for HIV Elimination, Chicago, IL, USA.
Section of Infectious Diseases and Global Health, Department of Medicine, University of Chicago, 5841 S. Maryland Avenue, Chicago, IL, 60637, USA.
J Racial Ethn Health Disparities. 2025 Feb;12(1):89-99. doi: 10.1007/s40615-023-01853-6. Epub 2023 Nov 13.
Stigma contributes to health disparities including increased HIV vulnerability among minority communities. Black transgender women experience multiple forms of stigma (e.g., anticipated, experienced), which can result in poor HIV-related outcomes. We utilized an adapted social ecological model (ASEM) to better understand the levels at which stigma is encountered and its impact on lived experience, particularly related to making healthcare decisions.
Semi-structured interviews and two focus groups (n = 38) were conducted with Black transgender women and Black transfeminine individuals in Chicago from 2016 to 2017. Participants were asked about discrimination in the community, healthcare experiences, and their thoughts and decision-making process with their healthcare provider regarding HIV pre-exposure prophylaxis. We conducted thematic analysis and organized our findings based on the levels of the ASEM: individual, interpersonal, organizational, community, and structural.
Participants experienced and anticipated stigma at each ASEM level. Stigma was not experienced in isolation: stigma experienced at one level caused anticipated stigma at other levels and internalized stigma leading to negative self-image. In each case, stigma adversely impacted health outcomes (e.g., medication nonadherence, disengagement from care). Stigma within healthcare settings, medication-related stigma, and stigma directed at appearance and identity are particularly detrimental to shared decision-making with a healthcare provider.
Recognizing and valuing Black transgender women's experience with stigma are essential for developing social and structural interventions that may work collaboratively across multiple levels of lived experience to reduce stigma and healthcare disparities faced by Black transgender women.
耻辱感导致了健康差异,包括少数族裔社区中感染艾滋病毒的易感性增加。黑人跨性别女性经历多种形式的耻辱感(例如预期的、实际经历的),这可能导致与艾滋病毒相关的不良后果。我们采用了一种适应性社会生态模型(ASEM),以更好地了解耻辱感出现的层面及其对生活经历的影响,特别是与医疗保健决策相关的影响。
2016年至2017年,对芝加哥的黑人跨性别女性和黑人跨女性个体进行了半结构化访谈和两个焦点小组(n = 38)。参与者被问及社区中的歧视、医疗保健经历,以及她们与医疗保健提供者就艾滋病毒暴露前预防的想法和决策过程。我们进行了主题分析,并根据ASEM的层面(个人、人际、组织、社区和结构)来组织我们的研究结果。
参与者在ASEM的每个层面都经历了并预期会有耻辱感。耻辱感并非孤立存在:在一个层面经历的耻辱感会导致在其他层面预期的耻辱感以及内化的耻辱感,从而导致负面的自我形象。在每种情况下,耻辱感都会对健康结果产生不利影响(例如药物治疗不依从、脱离医疗护理)。医疗保健环境中的耻辱感、与药物相关的耻辱感以及针对外表和身份的耻辱感对与医疗保健提供者的共同决策尤其有害。
认识并重视黑人跨性别女性的耻辱感经历,对于制定社会和结构性干预措施至关重要,这些干预措施可能在生活经历的多个层面协同发挥作用,以减少黑人跨性别女性面临的耻辱感和医疗保健差异。