Schillen Philip, In der Schmitten Jürgen, Danielzik Katja, Hillal Ellen, Moebus Susanne, Dehnen Alessia
Institut für Allgemeinmedizin, Universität Duisburg-Essen Medizinische Fakultät, Essen, Germany.
Institut für Urban Public Health, Universitätsklinikum Essen, Essen, Germany.
Gesundheitswesen. 2023 Dec;85(12):1131-1139. doi: 10.1055/a-2175-8290. Epub 2023 Nov 14.
Background As a large city in the middle of a metropolitan area, the city of Essen is characterized by strong social segregation and a north-south divide in the social status of its population. The conventional demand planning does not take such strong disparities within a planning unit into account. The present study aims to analyze the distribution of primary care structures using the example of two large urban areas within the city of Essen and to identify perspectives for strengthening primary care in disadvantaged urban areas. Methods First, a secondary data analysis was carried out at the district level and the study area Essen North (258,790 residents), consisting of 19 districts, was defined on the basis of two inclusion criteria - 1. location of the district north of the A40 freeway and 2. a mean subsistence rate>17.20 percent (average value of the city of Essen). Subsequently the study area was compared with the rest of the city (332,242 residents) with regard to the indicators a) social status, and b) available general practioners and pediatricians. The data of the selected indicators is based on the social reporting of the city of Essen and the "Online Practice Search" (Online-Praxissuche) of the Association of Statutory Health Insurance Physicians North Rhine. The resulting database (last update: 10/20212) was then evaluated at the district level and the primary care situation of the two urban areas was compared. Results The results revealed a significantly lower primary care coverage in the socially disadvantaged study area Essen North by about 25 percent for general practioners and by almost half for pediatricians. Thus, higher social disadvantage was associated with poorer access to primary care close to home, especially for children and adolescents. Conclusion The distribution of primary care providers in the city of Essen increases the risk of contributing to the manifestation of geographic disparities and health inequalities. The existing planning system in particular is not suitable for addressing the threatening or already existing undersupply of primary health care to the population in disadvantaged urban districts.
作为大都市地区中部的一座大城市,埃森市的特点是社会隔离严重,其人口的社会地位存在南北差异。传统的需求规划并未考虑规划单元内如此巨大的差异。本研究旨在以埃森市内两个大型城区为例,分析初级保健机构的分布情况,并确定加强弱势城区初级保健的前景。方法:首先,在区一级进行了二次数据分析,并根据两个纳入标准确定了研究区域埃森北区(258,790名居民),该区域由19个区组成——1. 区位于A40高速公路以北;2. 平均维持生计率>17.20%(埃森市平均值)。随后,将该研究区域与该市其他地区(332,242名居民)在以下指标方面进行了比较:a) 社会地位,以及b) 现有的全科医生和儿科医生。所选指标的数据基于埃森市的社会报告以及北莱茵法定医疗保险医生协会的“在线诊所搜索”(Online-Praxissuche)。然后在区一级对所得数据库(最后更新时间:2021年10月)进行评估,并比较了两个城区初级保健的情况。结果:结果显示,在社会弱势的研究区域埃森北区,初级保健覆盖率显著较低,全科医生的覆盖率低约25%,儿科医生的覆盖率低近一半。因此,社会劣势程度越高,越难在家附近获得初级保健服务,尤其是儿童和青少年。结论:埃森市初级保健提供者的分布增加了导致地理差异和健康不平等现象显现的风险。特别是现有的规划系统不适用于解决弱势城区居民面临的初级卫生保健供应不足的威胁或已存在的供应不足问题。