Pantha Sandesh, Jones Martin, Gray Richard
School of Nursing and Midwifery, La Trobe University, Bundoora, VIC 3086, Australia.
Department of Rural Health, University of South Australia, Whyalla Noorie, SA 5608, Australia.
Nurs Rep. 2023 Nov 6;13(4):1607-1623. doi: 10.3390/nursrep13040133.
There is some evidence that aspects of nurse-doctor communication are associated with the quality of care and treatment patients receive whilst they are in hospital. To date, no studies have examined stakeholder perceptions on how patient care is influenced by clinical communication between nurses and doctors. We conducted a concept mapping study to generate a deep understanding of how clinical communication impacts patient care. Concept mapping has six phases: preparation, idea generation, structuring, representation, interpretation, and utilization. A total of 20 patients, 21 nurses, and 21 doctors participated in the study. Brainstorming generated 69 discreet statements about how nurse-doctor communication impacts patient care. The structuring (rating and clustering) phase was completed by 48 participants. The data interpretation workshop selected a five-cluster solution: effective communication, trust, patient safety, impediments to patient care, and interpersonal skills. On the final concept map, the five clusters were arranged in a circle around the center of the map. Clusters were relatively equal in size, suggesting that each concept makes a broadly equal contribution to how nurse-doctor communication influences patient care. Our study suggests that there are multiple aspects of clinical communication that impact patient care. Candidate interventions to enhance nurse-doctor communication may need to consider the complex nature of interprofessional working. Registration: This study was prospectively registered with the Open Science Framework (OSF) on 09.07.2020 (osf.io/9np8v/) prior to recruiting the first participant.
有证据表明,护士与医生之间沟通的某些方面与患者在住院期间接受的护理和治疗质量相关。迄今为止,尚无研究探讨利益相关者对护士与医生之间的临床沟通如何影响患者护理的看法。我们进行了一项概念映射研究,以深入了解临床沟通如何影响患者护理。概念映射有六个阶段:准备、想法生成、构建、呈现、解释和应用。共有20名患者、21名护士和21名医生参与了该研究。头脑风暴产生了69条关于护士与医生沟通如何影响患者护理的独立陈述。48名参与者完成了构建(评级和聚类)阶段。数据解释研讨会选择了一个五类解决方案:有效沟通、信任、患者安全、患者护理障碍和人际技能。在最终的概念图上,这五个类别围绕地图中心呈圆形排列。各聚类大小相对相等,这表明每个概念对护士与医生沟通如何影响患者护理的贡献大致相同。我们的研究表明,临床沟通有多个方面会影响患者护理。增强护士与医生沟通的候选干预措施可能需要考虑跨专业工作的复杂性。注册情况:本研究在招募第一名参与者之前,于2020年7月9日在开放科学框架(OSF)上进行了前瞻性注册(osf.io/9np8v/)。