Division of Cardiology, Albert Einstein College of Medicine at Montefiore Health System, NY (L.D.B., J.M., F.Z., A.L., N.C., X.Z.).
Biosense Webster, Irvine, CA/Yokne'am, Israel (V.G., J.M., S.F.-H., T.S., C.B., A.G.).
Circ Arrhythm Electrophysiol. 2023 Dec;16(12):663-671. doi: 10.1161/CIRCEP.123.012344. Epub 2023 Nov 23.
Pulsed field ablation (PFA) has emerged as an alternative to radiofrequency ablation. However, data on focal point-by-point PFA are scarce. The aim of this study was to compare lesion durability and collateral damage between focally delivered unipolar/biphasic PFA versus radiofrequency in swine.
Eighteen swine were randomized to low-dose PFA, high-dose PFA, and radiofrequency using a multimodality generator. Radiofrequency delivered by market-available generator served as control group. A contact force-sensing catheter was used to focally deliver PFA/radiofrequency at the pulmonary veins and other predefined sites in the atria. Animals were remapped postprocedurally and 28 days postablation to test lesion durability followed by gross necroscopy and histology.
All targeted sites were successfully ablated (contact force value, 13.9±4.1 g). Follow-up remapping showed persistent pulmonary vein isolation in all animals (100%) with lesion durability at nonpulmonary vein sites proven in most (98%). Regardless of the energy source used, the lesion size was similar across the study groups. Transmurality was achieved in 95% of targeted sites and 100% at pulmonary veins. On histology, PFA animals showed more mature scar formation than their radiofrequency counterpart without myocardial necrosis or inflammation. Finally, no sign of collateral damage was observed in any of the groups.
In a randomized preclinical study, focally delivered unipolar/biphasic PFA guided by contact force values was associated with durable lesions on chronic remapping and with mature scar formation on histology without signs of collateral injury on necroscopy. Further studies are needed to investigate the long-term feasibility of this new approach to atrial fibrillation treatment.
脉冲场消融(PFA)已成为射频消融的替代方法。然而,关于逐点聚焦 PFA 的数据很少。本研究旨在比较猪的单点传递的单极/双相 PFA 与射频消融在致伤持久性和侧支损伤方面的差异。
18 头猪随机分为低剂量 PFA 组、高剂量 PFA 组和射频组,采用多模态发生器。市场上可用的发生器提供的射频作为对照组。使用接触力感应导管在肺静脉和心房其他预定部位进行单点传递的 PFA/射频消融。动物在术后和消融后 28 天进行再次映射以测试致伤持久性,然后进行大体解剖和组织学检查。
所有靶向部位均成功消融(接触力值为 13.9±4.1 g)。随访再次映射显示所有动物均实现了持续性肺静脉隔离(100%),大多数非肺静脉部位的致伤持久性也得到了证实(98%)。无论使用何种能量源,各组的致伤大小相似。95%的靶向部位达到了透壁性,100%的肺静脉达到了透壁性。组织学上,PFA 动物的瘢痕形成比射频动物更成熟,没有心肌坏死或炎症。最后,在任何一组中都没有观察到侧支损伤的迹象。
在一项随机的临床前研究中,基于接触力值引导的单点传递的单极/双相 PFA 在慢性再次映射时可产生持久性致伤,在组织学上可形成成熟的瘢痕,大体解剖时无侧支损伤的迹象。需要进一步的研究来探讨这种新的房颤治疗方法的长期可行性。