Department for Operations, Technology, Events and Hospitality Management, Manchester Metropolitan University, Manchester M15 6BH, UK.
Research Department, Centrum Católica Graduate Business School (CCGBS), Pontificia Universidad Católica del Perú (PUCP), Lima 15023, Peru.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2023 Nov 20;20(22):7084. doi: 10.3390/ijerph20227084.
(1) Background: Health literacy (HL) debates have increased significantly in the last two decades. HL concepts/themes and models have achieved substantial development in the US and Europe. Although there have been some efforts to develop HL in Latin America and the Caribbean (LAC), these seem to be few and scattered. This paper reviews and discusses developments of HL concepts and themes globally and in LAC over the last two decades. (2) Purpose: This study aimed to identify the prevalent health literacy concepts/themes deployed globally and in LAC as reported in academic journals from 2005 to 2022. We looked into which fields of knowledge have been informing HL research over the last decades. (3) Methods: We conducted a structured search on the Web of Science (WoS), Scopus, PubMed, and SciELO databases to extract the textual data for bibliometric analysis. We analyzed the textual data with VOSviewer and Biblioshiny to better understand health literacy themes and strands currently being researched in the LAC region. We conducted the searches in two periods: the first in May 2023 and the second in October 2023. (4) Results: The bibliometric study highlighted five WoS categories informing most HL global studies: (i) public environmental occupational health; (ii) environmental sciences; (iii) health policy services; (iv) health care science services; and (v) communication. The two predominant categories in LAC are public environmental occupation health and health policy services. Journals hosting HL publications come from these WoS categories. Themes in HL publications can be organized into four thematic clusters: (i) (research designs, analytic techniques, and criteria for examining HL data); (ii) (measurement properties of data collection tools); (iii) (practical issues related to implementing HL programs); and (iv) (effectiveness of HL programs on mental health and illness treatment). (5) Conclusions: There is expanding interest in health literacy among scholars. The number of publications has increased substantially, particularly over the last five years. These are dominated by the Global North. The metrics show that LAC and Africa are trailing in publications. There is an emerging focus on adult literacy, functional/low health literacy, and their effect on improving capabilities, comprehension, and communication regarding health-related topics.
(1) 背景:健康素养(HL)的研究在过去二十年中显著增加。HL 的概念/主题和模型在美国和欧洲得到了实质性的发展。尽管拉丁美洲和加勒比地区(LAC)也有一些发展 HL 的努力,但这些努力似乎很少且分散。本文回顾并讨论了过去二十年全球和 LAC 地区 HL 概念和主题的发展。(2) 目的:本研究旨在确定 2005 年至 2022 年学术期刊中报道的全球和 LAC 地区普遍使用的健康素养概念/主题。我们研究了过去几十年哪些知识领域一直在为 HL 研究提供信息。(3) 方法:我们在 Web of Science (WoS)、Scopus、PubMed 和 SciELO 数据库上进行了结构化搜索,以提取文献计量分析的文本数据。我们使用 VOSviewer 和 Biblioshiny 对文本数据进行分析,以更好地了解目前在 LAC 地区正在研究的健康素养主题和线索。我们分两个阶段进行搜索:第一阶段是 2023 年 5 月,第二阶段是 2023 年 10 月。(4) 结果:文献计量研究突出了五个最能反映全球 HL 研究的 WoS 类别:(i) 公共环境卫生职业健康;(ii) 环境科学;(iii) 卫生政策服务;(iv) 医疗保健科学服务;和 (v) 沟通。LAC 的两个主要类别是公共环境卫生职业健康和卫生政策服务。发表 HL 出版物的期刊来自这些 WoS 类别。HL 出版物的主题可以组织成四个主题集群:(i) (研究设计、分析技术和检查 HL 数据的标准);(ii) (数据收集工具的测量特性);(iii) (与实施 HL 计划相关的实际问题);和 (iv) (HL 计划对心理健康和疾病治疗的有效性)。(5) 结论:学者们对健康素养的兴趣不断扩大。出版物的数量大幅增加,尤其是在过去五年中。这些出版物主要来自北方国家。指标显示,LAC 和非洲在出版物方面落后。人们越来越关注成人识字率、功能性/低健康素养及其对提高与健康相关主题的能力、理解和沟通的影响。