Department of Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Harvard Medical School.
Department of Pediatrics, University of California San Diego, USA.
Curr Opin Endocrinol Diabetes Obes. 2024 Feb 1;31(1):43-52. doi: 10.1097/MED.0000000000000845. Epub 2023 Nov 27.
A recent increase in legislation in the United States prohibiting gender-affirming care (GAC) for transgender youth follows a wave of its politicization despite support from all pertinent mainstream medical associations. This review describes the standards of GAC for transgender youth, the origins of legislation prohibiting this care, a review of current legislation in the United States and a discussion on the impact on patients, providers, and the medical field.
A critical evaluation of historical parallels and current organizations supporting this legislation reveals it stems not from concerns within the medical field but from political and religious interests. This intrusion sets a dangerous precedent, undermining evidence-based medicine, providers' ability to practice according to standards of care, and patients' and guardians' autonomy and medical decision-making. This wave of antitrans rhetoric and legislation has resulted in threats to health providers and hospitals, 'moral distress" in providers, and migration of providers and patients from hostile states.
Similar to antiabortion legislation, these legislative efforts will likely result in negative health outcomes and worsening disparities. The medical community must confront these forces directly through an understanding of the political and structural forces at play and adopting strategies to leverage collective power.
尽管所有相关主流医学协会都支持,但美国最近增加了禁止跨性别青年进行性别肯定护理(GAC)的立法,这是其政治化的一波浪潮。这篇综述描述了跨性别青年的 GAC 标准、禁止这种护理的立法起源、对美国当前立法的审查以及对患者、提供者和医疗领域的影响的讨论。
对历史类比和当前支持这项立法的组织的批判性评估表明,它不是源于医学界的担忧,而是源于政治和宗教利益。这种干预开创了一个危险的先例,破坏了循证医学、提供者按照护理标准行医的能力以及患者和监护人的自主权和医疗决策。这种反跨性别言论和立法浪潮已经对医疗保健提供者和医院构成威胁,导致提供者出现“道德困境”,以及提供者和患者从敌对州迁移。
与反堕胎立法类似,这些立法努力可能导致负面的健康结果和更大的差距。医学界必须通过了解发挥作用的政治和结构力量,并采取利用集体力量的策略,直接应对这些力量。