Department of Family Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, University of Ljubljana, Ljubljana, Slovenia.
Department of Clinical Skills, School of Medicine, University of Split, Split, Croatia.
Eur J Gen Pract. 2023 Dec;29(1):2283834. doi: 10.1080/13814788.2023.2283834. Epub 2023 Nov 27.
Similar to other countries, Departments of Family Medicine in the former Yugoslavia had to transition from face-to-face to distance education during COVID-19.
To elucidate obstacles and facilitators of the transition from face-to-face to distance education.
A cross-sectional, multicentre, qualitative study design was used to analyse nine open-ended questions from an online survey using inductive thematic analysis. The questionnaire was distributed to 21 medical schools, inviting them to involve at least two teachers/students/trainees. Data were collected between December 2021 and March 2022.
In 17 medical schools, 23 students, 54 trainees and 40 teachers participated. The following themes were identified: facilitators and barriers of transition, innovations for enhancing distance education, convenience of distance education, classical teaching for better communication, the future of distance education, reaching learning outcomes and experience of online assessment. Innovations referred mainly to new online technologies for interactive education and communication. Distance education allowed for greater flexibility in scheduling and self-directed learning; however, participants felt that classical education allowed better communication and practical learning. Teachers believed knowledge-related learning outcomes could be achieved through distance education but not teaching clinical skills. Participants anticipated a future where a combination of teaching methods is used.
The transition to distance education was made possible thanks to its flexible scheduling, innovative tools and possibility of self-directed learning. However, face-to-face education was considered preferable for fostering interpersonal relations and teaching clinical skills. Educators should strive to strike a balance between innovative approaches and the preservation of personal experiences.
与其他国家类似,前南斯拉夫的家庭医学系在 COVID-19 期间不得不从面对面教学转为远程教学。
阐明从面对面教学向远程教学过渡的障碍和促进因素。
采用横断面、多中心、定性研究设计,使用归纳主题分析方法分析在线调查中的 9 个开放式问题。该问卷分发给 21 所医学院校,邀请他们至少有 2 名教师/学生/学员参与。数据收集于 2021 年 12 月至 2022 年 3 月期间进行。
在 17 所医学院校中,有 23 名学生、54 名学员和 40 名教师参与了研究。确定了以下主题:过渡的促进因素和障碍、增强远程教育的创新、远程教育的便利性、提高沟通的经典教学、远程教育的未来、实现学习成果和在线评估经验。创新主要指用于互动教育和沟通的新在线技术。远程教育在安排时间和自主学习方面更加灵活;然而,参与者认为传统教育允许更好的沟通和实践学习。教师认为通过远程教育可以实现与知识相关的学习成果,但不能教授临床技能。参与者预计未来将采用多种教学方法相结合的方式。
由于其灵活的安排、创新工具和自主学习的可能性,远程教学得以实现。然而,面对面教育被认为更有利于培养人际关系和教授临床技能。教育工作者应努力在创新方法和保留个人经验之间取得平衡。