Zavala Gerardo A, Jennings Hannah Maria, Afaq Saima, Alam Ashraful, Ahmed Naveed, Aslam Faiza, Arsh Aatik, Coales Karen, Ekers David, Nabi Mumtahana, Naz Anum, Shakur Nayeema, Siddiqi Najma, Wright Judy M, Kellar Ian
Department of Health Sciences, University of York, York, United Kingdom.
Hull York Medical School, York, United Kingdom.
Int J Ment Health. 2023 Apr 24;52(3):260-284. doi: 10.1080/00207411.2023.2202431. eCollection 2023.
We evaluate the effectiveness of psychological interventions for depression in people with NCDs in South Asia and explore the individual, organizational, and policy-level barriers and facilitators for the implementation and scaling up of these interventions. Eight databases (and local web pages) were searched in May 2022. We conducted random effects models to evaluate the pooled effect of psychological interventions on depression in people with NCDs. We extracted the individual, organizational, and policy level barriers and facilitators. We found five randomized control trials, nine qualitative studies, and 35 policy documents that fitted the inclusion criteria. The pooled standardized mean difference in depression comparing psychological interventions with usual care was -2.31 (95% CI, -4.16 to -0.45; = .015, = 96.0%). We found barriers and facilitators to intervention delivery, mental health appears in the policy agenda in Bangladesh and Pakistan. However, there is a lack of policies relating to training in mental health for NCD health providers and a lack of integration of mental health care with NCD care. All of the psychological interventions reported to be effective in treating depression in this population. There are important delivery and policy barriers to the implementation and scaling up of psychological interventions for people with NCDs.
我们评估了南亚非传染性疾病患者抑郁症心理干预措施的有效性,并探讨了这些干预措施在实施和扩大规模方面的个人、组织及政策层面的障碍与促进因素。2022年5月检索了八个数据库(及本地网页)。我们采用随机效应模型评估心理干预措施对非传染性疾病患者抑郁症的综合效应。我们提取了个人、组织及政策层面的障碍与促进因素。我们发现五项随机对照试验、九项定性研究以及35份符合纳入标准的政策文件。将心理干预措施与常规护理相比,抑郁症的合并标准化均数差为-2.31(95%CI,-4.16至-0.45;P = 0.015,I² = 96.0%)。我们发现了干预措施实施方面的障碍与促进因素,心理健康在孟加拉国和巴基斯坦的政策议程中有所体现。然而,缺乏针对非传染性疾病医疗服务提供者的心理健康培训政策,且心理健康护理与非传染性疾病护理缺乏整合。据报告,所有心理干预措施对该人群的抑郁症治疗均有效。在为非传染性疾病患者实施和扩大心理干预措施方面存在重要的实施障碍和政策障碍。