Davidenko Nicolas, Day Jennifer
Department of Psychology, University of California, 1156 High Street, Social Sciences 2, Santa Cruz, CA, 95064, USA.
Mem Cognit. 2025 Jan;53(1):352-362. doi: 10.3758/s13421-023-01498-0. Epub 2023 Nov 28.
Humans' ability to draw faces accurately from memory is extremely rare. One source of difficulty is the drawing process itself, which requires converting a complex, three-dimensional mental representation to a two-dimensional drawing. To simplify the drawing process and more directly assess people's recall of faces, we used the Parameterized Face Drawing (PFD) model (Day & Davidenko, Visual Cognition, 26(2), 89-99, 2018; Day & Davidenko, Journal of Vision, 19(11):7, 1-12, 2019) to generate simplified face stimuli that non-artists could draw. In Experiment 1, participants (N = 37) completed a sequential drawing-by-copying task in which they were given 60 s to draw each of 18 target faces by copying them using a stylus on a touchscreen. Following each drawing, participants were prompted to label a set of 20 key points on their drawing based on a reference face, which were used to compute the drawing's accuracy. In Experiment 2, participants (N = 22) observed each target face for 15 s and were then given 60 s to draw it from memory. In Experiment 1, the accuracy of drawings improved slightly over the course of the 18 trials, although most of the improvement occurred during the first few trials. In Experiment 2 (drawing-from-memory), there was no evidence of improvement, although the null results are tentative given the small sample size. Despite weak evidence of learning, participants' drawings captured the likeness of the target faces significantly better than chance. We discuss implications of these findings for the use of drawing as a method of face recall.
人类从记忆中准确画出人脸的能力极为罕见。困难的一个来源是绘画过程本身,这需要将复杂的三维心理表征转换为二维绘画。为了简化绘画过程并更直接地评估人们对人脸的记忆,我们使用了参数化人脸绘画(PFD)模型(戴 & 达维坚科,《视觉认知》,26(2),89 - 99,2018;戴 & 达维坚科,《视觉杂志》,19(11):7,1 - 12,2019)来生成非艺术家也能画出的简化人脸刺激。在实验1中,参与者(N = 37)完成了一项逐幅临摹绘画任务,他们有60秒时间使用触控笔在触摸屏上临摹18张目标人脸中的每一张。每次绘画后,参与者被要求根据一张参考人脸在自己的画上标记一组20个关键点,这些关键点用于计算绘画的准确性。在实验2中,参与者(N = 22)观察每张目标人脸15秒,然后有60秒时间凭记忆画出它。在实验1中,绘画的准确性在18次试验过程中略有提高,不过大部分提高发生在前几次试验中。在实验2(凭记忆绘画)中,没有证据表明有提高,不过鉴于样本量小,零结果只是初步的。尽管学习的证据微弱,但参与者的绘画显著比随机水平更能捕捉到目标人脸的 likeness。我们讨论了这些发现对于将绘画用作人脸记忆方法的意义。