Kerry Nicholas, Chhabra Ria, Clifton Jeremy D W
Positive Psychology Center, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, USA.
Psychol Res Behav Manag. 2023 Nov 28;16:4799-4816. doi: 10.2147/PRBM.S372432. eCollection 2023.
Many studies suggest a link between gratitude and life satisfaction, including experimental tests of gratitude interventions. This paper presents a systematic review of recent literature on the influence of gratitude on life satisfaction. The aim of this research is to better understand the nature of the relationship between gratitude and life satisfaction and to evaluate the state of literature.
A systematic search was conducted using four databases (APA PsycInfo, Scopus, Web of Science, and EBSCO), targeting articles published since 2010. Correlational studies were included if they used the GQ6 measure of gratitude and the Satisfaction With Life Scale (SWLS). Intervention studies were included if they reported effects of a gratitude manipulation on SWLS scores. Forty-four articles (N = 16,529) focusing on gratitude and life satisfaction were ultimately selected. Among the selected studies, 18 employed experimental designs and 26 were cross-sectional studies. Five studies also presented cross-lagged analyses from two or more timepoints.
The review indicated a substantial positive correlation between gratitude and life satisfaction. Various potential mediators were also identified, including meaning in life, social support, and self-esteem. Some experimental research suggested that gratitude interventions may increase life satisfaction compared to neutral control conditions, although evidence was mixed. There was stronger evidence for these effects in people from Western countries. However, there is no strong evidence that gratitude interventions outperform positively valenced control conditions. Thus, it is possible that the effects of intervention could be caused by demand- or placebo effects.
While it is clear that there is a link between gratitude and life satisfaction, the extent to which gratitude causes life satisfaction and the mechanism underlying that link require further exploration. We suggest that experimental work test effects of changes in gratitude that cannot be explained by placebo- or demand effects. We also encourage more interactive interventions as well as research that investigates third variables that could underlie both gratitude and life satisfaction.
许多研究表明感恩与生活满意度之间存在联系,包括感恩干预的实验测试。本文对近期关于感恩对生活满意度影响的文献进行了系统综述。本研究的目的是更好地理解感恩与生活满意度之间关系的本质,并评估文献状况。
使用四个数据库(美国心理学会心理学文摘数据库、Scopus、科学引文索引和EBSCO)进行系统检索,目标是2010年以来发表的文章。如果相关研究使用感恩量表(GQ6)和生活满意度量表(SWLS),则纳入相关性研究。如果干预研究报告了感恩操纵对SWLS分数的影响,则纳入此类研究。最终选定了44篇关注感恩与生活满意度的文章(N = 16,529)。在选定的研究中,18项采用了实验设计,26项为横断面研究。五项研究还展示了来自两个或更多时间点的交叉滞后分析。
综述表明感恩与生活满意度之间存在显著正相关。还确定了各种潜在的中介因素,包括生活意义、社会支持和自尊。一些实验研究表明,与中性对照条件相比,感恩干预可能会提高生活满意度,尽管证据不一。西方国家的人群中这些效应的证据更强。然而,没有强有力的证据表明感恩干预优于正价对照条件。因此,干预效果可能是由需求效应或安慰剂效应引起的。
虽然感恩与生活满意度之间存在联系这一点很明确,但感恩导致生活满意度的程度以及该联系背后的机制需要进一步探索。我们建议实验工作测试感恩变化的效果,这些效果不能用安慰剂或需求效应来解释。我们还鼓励更多的互动干预以及研究那些可能是感恩和生活满意度基础的第三变量。