Lee Minyoung, Park Yoon, Eun Seon-Deok, Ho Seung Hee
Department of Holistic Integrative Healing Studies, Seoul Cyber University, Seoul 01133, Republic of Korea.
Department of Clinical Rehabilitation Research, National Rehabilitation Research Institute, Seoul 01022, Republic of Korea.
Healthcare (Basel). 2023 Nov 24;11(23):3031. doi: 10.3390/healthcare11233031.
We developed a set of assessment tools for health professionals to evaluate the physical functions, mental functions, and social abilities of people with stroke (PWS) from 6 months to 3 years after stroke onset, to design a tailored "Rehabilitation Exercise and Sports" (RES) program, which the South Korean government was required to provide by the Act on Guarantee of Right to Health and Access to Health Services for people with disabilities. Since previous studies mainly dealt with the chronic stage of PWS, it would not be appropriate to apply assessment tools used in previous studies, as they are not compatible with the time window (6 months to 3 years) used to define the target population of the RES program. We reviewed the literature to identify evaluation factors and assessment tools applied in previous studies, and developed a Delphi questionnaire with closed-ended questions based on the literature review's results and supplementary open-ended questions. A 20-expert panel conducted four rounds of the Delphi survey, including two rounds to determine evaluation factors and two rounds to determine assessment tools. The Delphi survey revealed that 22 evaluation factors and 24 corresponding assessment tools reached consensus among the experts. However, no assessment tools reached consensus for three evaluation factors: muscle endurance, flexibility, and dynamic balance. A comprehensive set of assessment tools would be useful for health professionals to understand the health status of PWS from 6 months to 3 years after stroke onset, and help the design of tailored RES programs.
我们为健康专业人员开发了一套评估工具,用于评估中风患者(PWS)在中风发作后6个月至3年的身体功能、心理功能和社交能力,以设计量身定制的“康复运动与体育”(RES)计划,韩国政府根据《残疾人健康权保障及医疗服务获取法》被要求提供该计划。由于先前的研究主要涉及中风患者的慢性阶段,应用先前研究中使用的评估工具并不合适,因为它们与用于定义RES计划目标人群的时间窗口(6个月至3年)不兼容。我们查阅了文献,以确定先前研究中应用的评估因素和评估工具,并根据文献综述的结果和补充的开放式问题编制了一份带有封闭式问题的德尔菲问卷。一个由20名专家组成的小组进行了四轮德尔菲调查,包括两轮确定评估因素和两轮确定评估工具。德尔菲调查显示,22个评估因素和24个相应的评估工具在专家之间达成了共识。然而,对于肌肉耐力、柔韧性和动态平衡这三个评估因素,没有评估工具达成共识。一套全面的评估工具将有助于健康专业人员了解中风患者在中风发作后6个月至3年的健康状况,并有助于设计量身定制的RES计划。