Department of Computer Engineering and Information Technology, Shiraz University of Technology, Shiraz, Iran.
Int J Med Inform. 2024 Feb;182:105304. doi: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2023.105304. Epub 2023 Nov 28.
Healthcare is a social and economic challenge in many countries, exacerbated by today's increasing demand. Many studies demonstrate that hospitals that move towards smartness, and some of their processes are smart, can provide more appropriate treatments and deal with problems more flexibly. It is axiomatic that implementing smart hospitals and healthcare tools requires a clear objective. However, the concept of a smart hospital lacks a comprehensive and broadly accepted definition, leading to varied interpretations and misconceptions. Many developments touted as 'smart' merely digitize existing hospital environments without truly embracing the full potential of smart technology. Furthermore, research studies have neglected to consider industrial perspectives, which will soon cause a gap between industry and academics in this concept.
This research aims to explore the attributes of a smart hospital and use them to propose a definition for it, considering both scholarly and industrial viewpoints.
The PRISMA method is employed to select academic and practical papers providing definitions and insights into smart hospitals or healthcare. 17 studies are analyzed, and a total, 83 characteristics are identified to describe the smart hospital. These features are categorized into three primary categories: "technologies", "services", and "goals". The most important features are determined by analyzing the frequencies of these characteristics across all the studies. In the results section, these data are presented in graphical form, highlighting both academic and industrial perspectives separately, as well as a combined analysis. Furthermore, an attempt is made to uncover trends in smart hospitals from 2015 to 2023.
A comprehensive definition of the smart hospital, encompassing both academic and industrial perspectives, is proposed using the investigated characteristics. This study also presents research opportunities and discusses the existing gap between academia and industry concerning smart hospitals.
医疗保健是许多国家面临的社会和经济挑战,而当今需求的不断增长加剧了这一挑战。许多研究表明,向智能化迈进并使部分流程智能化的医院能够提供更合适的治疗方案,并更灵活地应对问题。不言而喻,实施智能医院和医疗保健工具需要明确的目标。然而,智能医院的概念缺乏全面和广泛接受的定义,导致了不同的解释和误解。许多被吹捧为“智能”的发展只是将现有医院环境数字化,而没有真正发挥智能技术的全部潜力。此外,研究忽视了考虑工业视角,这将很快导致该概念在学术界和工业界之间出现差距。
本研究旨在探讨智能医院的属性,并从学术和工业的角度出发,提出一个对其的定义。
采用 PRISMA 方法选择提供智能医院或医疗保健定义和见解的学术和实践论文。分析了 17 项研究,并确定了 83 个特征来描述智能医院。这些特征分为三个主要类别:“技术”、“服务”和“目标”。通过分析所有研究中这些特征的频率,确定了最重要的特征。在结果部分,这些数据以图形形式呈现,分别突出了学术和工业视角,以及综合分析。此外,还试图揭示 2015 年至 2023 年智能医院的发展趋势。
使用研究的特征,提出了一个全面的智能医院定义,包含学术和工业视角。本研究还提出了研究机会,并讨论了学术界和工业界在智能医院方面存在的差距。