Bailo Paolo, Gibelli Filippo, Celletti Asaea, Caraffa Anna, Sirignano Ascanio, Ricci Giovanna
Section of Legal Medicine, School of Law, University of Camerino (MC), Camerino, Italy.
Crim Behav Ment Health. 2023 Dec;33(6):441-454. doi: 10.1002/cbm.2319. Epub 2023 Dec 11.
Suicide is a leading cause of death globally, with approximately 800,000 deaths annually and accounting for 1.5% of all deaths. Risk factors are multifaceted, encompassing individual factors (such as genetics, family history and mental illnesses) and environmental factors (such as economic conditions, social support and life events). In prisons, suicide rates are markedly higher than in the general population, particularly in Italy, where the prisoner suicide rate is approximately 20 times that of the non-incarcerated population. There is, however, little research on suicide in Italian prisons.
To analyse the characteristics of all people who died by suicide in Italian prisons between 2010 and 2020.
We carried out a records-based cohort study analysing official data from the Italian Ministry of Justice on prison suicides between 2010 and 2020. The data were cross-referenced and, when required, supplemented with information from Ristretti Orizzonti, a journal specialising in health and living conditions in prisons, as well as from the website of ISTAT (Italian National Statistical Institute), newspapers, radio broadcasts and news agencies.
Factors associated with an increased risk of suicide in prisons were nighttime periods, the months of June, July and October, a relatively brief duration of detention (<6 months), having been convicted of murder, male gender, being about 40 years old, having access to hanging materials and being interned (i.e. subjected to the execution of custodial security measures) or awaiting trial. Prison overcrowding was not a risk factor for suicide.
Our findings hold substantial implications for suicide prevention in Italian prisons as they suggest both characteristics of individuals and characteristics of the institutions that could be taken as risk indicators. This knowledge can inform the development of targeted interventions to manage both individual and environmental factors better, leading to improved prison conditions and reduced suicide rates. Furthermore, our research establishes a foundation for more systematic and in-depth investigations that could further improve suicide prevention strategies in Italian prisons, ultimately influencing policy changes in both practice and research, including perhaps establishing a national database on every completed suicide in prisons.
自杀是全球主要的死亡原因之一,每年约有80万人自杀死亡,占总死亡人数的1.5%。风险因素是多方面的,包括个体因素(如遗传、家族病史和精神疾病)和环境因素(如经济状况、社会支持和生活事件)。在监狱中,自杀率明显高于普通人群,尤其是在意大利,囚犯自杀率约为非监禁人群的20倍。然而,关于意大利监狱自杀情况的研究很少。
分析2010年至2020年间在意大利监狱自杀死亡的所有人的特征。
我们开展了一项基于记录的队列研究,分析了意大利司法部关于2010年至2020年间监狱自杀情况的官方数据。对数据进行了交叉核对,并在需要时补充了《Ristretti Orizzonti》(一份专门关注监狱健康和生活条件的期刊)、意大利国家统计局网站、报纸、广播和新闻机构提供的信息。
与监狱自杀风险增加相关的因素包括夜间时段、6月、7月和10月、拘留时间相对较短(<6个月)、被判谋杀罪、男性、年龄约40岁、能获取上吊材料以及被监禁(即受到监禁安全措施管束)或候审。监狱过度拥挤并非自杀风险因素。
我们的研究结果对意大利监狱的自杀预防具有重要意义,因为它们揭示了可作为风险指标的个体特征和机构特征。这些知识可为制定有针对性的干预措施提供参考,以便更好地管理个体和环境因素,从而改善监狱条件并降低自杀率。此外,我们的研究为更系统深入的调查奠定了基础,这可能会进一步改进意大利监狱的自杀预防策略,最终影响实践和研究中的政策变化,或许包括建立一个关于监狱中每起自杀事件的国家数据库。