Aon Maha, Oberconz Simon, Brasholt Marie
Prevention and Accountability Department, DIGNITY - Danish Institute against Torture, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Epidemiology and Population Health Department, Faculty of Health Sciences, American University of Beirut, Beirut, Lebanon.
BMC Public Health. 2025 Jul 2;25(1):2218. doi: 10.1186/s12889-025-23340-9.
It is estimated that the majority of prisons globally are overcrowded. There is consensus that overcrowding leads to negative health outcomes, however quantitative research of this association appears limited. This scoping review aimed to identify literature examining the association between prison overcrowding and health outcomes, and to summarize these associations. Two databases and a grey literature site were searched for quantitative studies where overcrowding was an independent variable, and the outcome was any physical or mental health issue. This yielded 34 records from 16 mostly high-income countries in addition to three multi-country studies. Studies applied a range of definitions of overcrowding with the most common being occupancy rates. Studies mostly concluded that overcrowding had a positive association on the outcome under study, i.e., as overcrowding increased so did the prevalence of the disease under study. When methodological limitations were taken into consideration, we found that in eighteen articles prison overcrowding was independently and positively associated with tuberculosis, COVID-19, self-harm, depression, overall prison mortality, and injuries due to violence respectively. Prison overcrowding was not found to be independently associated with suicide in four of the five studies where it featured.
据估计,全球大多数监狱都人满为患。人们一致认为,过度拥挤会导致负面的健康结果,然而,对这种关联的定量研究似乎有限。本综述旨在识别研究监狱过度拥挤与健康结果之间关联的文献,并总结这些关联。我们在两个数据库和一个灰色文献网站上搜索了定量研究,其中过度拥挤是自变量,结果是任何身体或心理健康问题。除了三项多国研究外,这还产生了来自16个主要高收入国家的34条记录。研究对过度拥挤采用了一系列定义,最常见的是入住率。研究大多得出结论,过度拥挤与所研究的结果呈正相关,即随着过度拥挤程度的增加,所研究疾病的患病率也会增加。当考虑到方法学上的局限性时,我们发现,在18篇文章中,监狱过度拥挤分别与结核病、COVID-19、自残、抑郁症、监狱总体死亡率以及暴力伤害独立且呈正相关。在五项涉及监狱过度拥挤的研究中,有四项未发现其与自杀存在独立关联。