Burbach F R, Schomer H H
S Afr Med J. 1987 Jan 24;71(2):93-7.
Forty-two obese women participated in two successive 3-month diet-exercise programmes. A stress questionnaire was answered on commencement, after 1 1/2 and 3 months (38 subjects), and after 6 months (30 subjects). A discussion group, informal counselling and in-depth interviews (12 subjects) provided reliable additional data. The hypothesis that subjects with juvenile-onset obesity experience greater stress on the programme and are less successful, was unsupported. The semistructured interviews indicated: that stress is inherent in dieting; that the compensatory effect of exercise mediates the loss of eating as a stress-coping mechanism; and that as goal weight is approached, a serious emotional crisis is experienced, due to the loss of the obese state as a defence. Negative findings from the stress questionnaire, and the patterns which emerged from the interviews, are conceptualised in terms of a general model of reactions to weight loss, which is based on a postulated homeostatic mechanism to maintain acceptable stress levels.
42名肥胖女性参加了两个连续的为期3个月的饮食-运动计划。在开始时、1个半月和3个月后(38名受试者)以及6个月后(30名受试者),她们填写了一份压力调查问卷。一个讨论小组、非正式咨询和深度访谈(12名受试者)提供了可靠的额外数据。关于青少年期发病的肥胖受试者在该计划中经历更大压力且成功率较低的假设未得到支持。半结构化访谈表明:节食中压力是固有的;运动的补偿作用介导了作为压力应对机制的进食行为的丧失;并且随着目标体重的接近,由于肥胖状态作为一种防御机制的丧失,会经历严重的情绪危机。压力调查问卷的负面结果以及访谈中出现的模式,根据一个基于假定的稳态机制以维持可接受压力水平的减肥反应通用模型进行了概念化。