Departament de Didàctica de la Llengua i la Literatura, i de les Ciències Socials, Facultat de Ciències de l'Educació, Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain.
Centro de Investigação em Ciência Psicológica (CICPSI), Faculdade de Psicologia, Universidade de Lisboa, Lisboa, Portugal.
PLoS One. 2023 Dec 21;18(12):e0295606. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0295606. eCollection 2023.
Effective literacy skills are essential to actively participate in today's society. However, little research has been conducted that examined the impact of contextual variables on literacy development. The present paper addressed whether and how the socioeconomic status of the school (S-SES) children attend affects their literacy achievements. Eight-hundred and seventy-eight 2nd and 4th grade children participated in the study. Data were collected in low-SES (vulnerable) and in mid-high-SES (non-vulnerable) schools. Children completed a large battery of language, cognitive, and literacy tasks in Catalan, a language spoken in a region in Spain where virtually all children are at least bilingual (they also speak Spanish) and it is the main language of instruction. Results showed that children in vulnerable schools were outperformed by children in non-vulnerable schools across all literacy competencies, but particularly affected higher order skills; that is, text quality and reading comprehension. Differences with their non-vulnerable peers remained, even after controlling for context-level covariates, including familial SES. However, S-SES ceased to exert significant influence once children's cognitive and, especially, linguistic skills were considered. The study adds to previous research claiming that school SES has an effect on students' literacy skills, above and beyond children's home SES. However, our findings also suggest that literacy performance is ultimately mostly dependent on educationally actionable, subject-level skills. Educational implications are discussed.
有效读写能力对于积极参与当今社会至关重要。然而,很少有研究考察情境变量对读写发展的影响。本文探讨了儿童就读学校的社会经济地位(S-SES)是否以及如何影响他们的读写成绩。878 名 2 年级和 4 年级的儿童参与了这项研究。数据是在低 SES(弱势)和中高 SES(非弱势)学校收集的。儿童在加泰罗尼亚语中完成了大量的语言、认知和读写任务,加泰罗尼亚语是西班牙一个地区使用的语言,几乎所有的儿童至少都是双语(他们也说西班牙语),而且它是主要的教学语言。研究结果表明,弱势学校的儿童在所有读写能力方面都不如非弱势学校的儿童,尤其是在高阶技能方面,即文本质量和阅读理解。即使考虑到包括家庭 SES 在内的情境水平协变量,弱势学校的儿童与非弱势学校的同龄人之间仍存在差异。然而,一旦考虑到儿童的认知能力,尤其是语言能力,S-SES 就不再产生显著影响。这项研究增加了先前的研究,即学校 SES 对学生的读写能力有影响,超出了儿童的家庭 SES。然而,我们的研究结果还表明,读写成绩最终主要取决于可教育的、学科层面的技能。讨论了教育方面的启示。