Viola Thiago Wendt, de Carvalho Mônica Timm, Padoin Rita Carolina Pozzer Krumenauer, Kampff Adriana Justin Cerveira, Padoin Alexandre Vontobel
Graduate Program in Medicine and Health Sciences, School of Medicine, Pontifical Catholic University of Rio Grande Do Sul (PUCRS), Avenida Ipiranga 6690-Building 12, Room 804.1, Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil.
Graduate Program in Education, Polytechnic School, PUCRS, Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil.
Sci Rep. 2025 Aug 17;15(1):30131. doi: 10.1038/s41598-025-15644-y.
The investigation into differences in academic achievement between private and public school students has long been a focal point. The aim of this study was to compare oral reading fluency between private and public schools in the post-pandemic period. A total of 1296 participants were recruited from various Brazilian cities, spanning from the 2nd to the 5th grade of elementary school. Utilizing an artificial intelligence Universal Language Model from the Azure SST platform, the audio files were analyzed reflecting the commonly spoken language in Portuguese, generating data on words read correctly per minute (WRCM), the percentage of correct words over incorrect words (PCW), average consecutive correct words (CCW), and average silence time between sentences (SBS). Statistical analysis involved linear mixed models followed by pairwise comparisons. The private school segment outperformed the public school segment in WRCM in the 4th grade and in PCW in the 3rd grade. Additionally, private schools were already reaching 5th-grade levels in WRCM during the 4th grade, and this effect was not evident within public schools. No differences were found regarding SBS and CCW. These findings highlight that differences between public and private schools concerning reading fluency may manifest during the early stages of elementary school.
对私立学校和公立学校学生学业成绩差异的调查长期以来一直是一个焦点。本研究的目的是比较疫情后私立学校和公立学校之间的口语阅读流利度。总共从巴西各个城市招募了1296名参与者,涵盖小学二年级到五年级。利用Azure SST平台的人工智能通用语言模型,对反映葡萄牙语常用口语的音频文件进行分析,生成每分钟正确阅读单词数(WRCM)、正确单词与错误单词的百分比(PCW)、平均连续正确单词数(CCW)以及句子之间的平均沉默时间(SBS)的数据。统计分析采用线性混合模型,随后进行成对比较。私立学校部分在四年级的WRCM和三年级的PCW方面优于公立学校部分。此外,私立学校在四年级时WRCM已达到五年级水平,而公立学校内这种效果并不明显。在SBS和CCW方面未发现差异。这些发现突出表明,公立学校和私立学校在阅读流利度方面的差异可能在小学早期阶段就会显现出来。