Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Vanderbilt University Medical Center, Nashville, TN.
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Louisiana State University Health Sciences Center - New Orleans, New Orleans, LA.
J Pediatr Orthop. 2024 Mar 1;44(3):e292-e297. doi: 10.1097/BPO.0000000000002606. Epub 2023 Dec 22.
Podcasts have become increasingly utilized in medical education over the past decade, especially in orthopaedic surgery. Compared with more traditional learning tools, podcasts are easily accessible, free, and capable of use while multitasking. Despite these apparent benefits, the effectiveness of podcasts as a dissemination tool for emerging peer-reviewed literature is not well understood. The Peds Ortho Podcast is the official podcast of Pediatric Orthopedic Society of North America that highlights recently published peer-reviewed articles through author interviews and executive summaries of featured articles. The purpose of this study was to compare the distribution of the Peds Ortho Podcast to traditional media by comparing electronic access statistics between the podcast episodes and the journal articles they summarize.
Podcast episodes were reviewed to catalog the abstracts and articles discussed therein. Because podcasts and articles utilize different electronic metrics to track distribution, we established a common metric of an "access," which we defined as an "intent to consume the media." For articles, we defined an "access" as the largest value of a publisher's online metrics, be it abstract views, full text views, or article downloads. For podcast episodes, we defined an "access" as any play >0 seconds. Access data were analyzed using independent samples t test and analyses of variance.
Eighty episodes of the Peds Ortho Podcast have featured 333 published, peer-reviewed articles to date, with 303 included in the final analysis with available article metrics. There were significantly more mean electronic accesses per podcast episode than featured articles (1236 vs. 482, P <0.001). Podcast consumption greatly varies in the first 30 days following episode release; however, recent episodes have a substantial proportion of accesses soon after publication.
Given that podcast electronic access is greater than traditional media, podcasts appear to be a valuable tool for health care providers and trainees. Podcasts serve a complementary role to traditional media by quickly disseminating main points and raising awareness of emerging research.
在过去十年中,播客在医学教育中得到了越来越多的应用,尤其是在矫形外科领域。与更传统的学习工具相比,播客更容易获取、免费且可以在多任务处理时使用。尽管有这些明显的优势,但播客作为新兴同行评议文献传播工具的有效性尚未得到很好的理解。《儿科矫形外科播客》(Peds Ortho Podcast)是北美小儿矫形外科协会的官方播客,通过对作者的采访和特色文章的执行摘要,突出介绍最近发表的同行评议文章。本研究的目的是通过比较播客节目和他们总结的期刊文章的电子访问统计数据,来比较《儿科矫形外科播客》与传统媒体的分布情况。
对播客节目进行了回顾,以对其中讨论的摘要和文章进行分类。由于播客和文章使用不同的电子指标来跟踪分布情况,我们建立了一个通用的“访问”指标,我们将其定义为“消费媒体的意图”。对于文章,我们将“访问”定义为出版商在线指标中的最大值,无论是摘要查看次数、全文查看次数还是文章下载次数。对于播客节目,我们将“访问”定义为任何播放时间超过 0 秒。使用独立样本 t 检验和方差分析对访问数据进行了分析。
截至目前,《儿科矫形外科播客》已播出 80 期,共涉及 333 篇已发表的同行评议文章,其中 303 篇文章的可用文章指标被纳入最终分析。每集播客的平均电子访问量明显多于每期节目中涉及的文章(1236 比 482,P <0.001)。播客节目的播放量在发布后的头 30 天内差异很大;然而,最近几期节目在发布后不久就有相当一部分的访问量。
鉴于播客的电子访问量大于传统媒体,播客似乎是医疗保健提供者和受训者的有价值工具。播客通过快速传播要点和提高对新兴研究的认识,与传统媒体形成互补。