Haar Rohini, Abdelrahman Sarah, Muzzall Evan, Aladhan Ibrahim, Shobak Kasim, Kawas Mohamad Rami, Aksh Aya, Blair Alden Hooper, Reingold Arthur, AlMhawish Naser
Division of Epidemiology, UC Berkeley School of Public Health, Berkeley, California, United States of America.
Evan Muzzall, Stanford Libraries, Stanford University, Palo Alto, California, United States of America.
PLOS Glob Public Health. 2023 Dec 27;3(12):e0002696. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgph.0002696. eCollection 2023.
Since 2011, Syria has been engulfed in a complex conflict marked by both targeted and indiscriminate attacks on civilians and civilian infrastructure. Water infrastructure has been continuously targeted, exacerbating problems with contamination of and access to clean adequate drinking water, and increasing the risk of waterborne diseases. We aimed to determine whether having access to more functional and chlorinated water stations is associated with a reduced risk of waterborne disease in northwest Syria. We examined the effect of functioning chlorinated water stations on the incidence of waterborne disease in 10 districts of Northwest Syria between January 1, 2017, and June 30, 2021, using weekly reported disease surveillance data and data from a water, sanitation, and hygiene (WASH) system evaluation program of the Assistance Coordination Unit (ACU). We ran eight negative binomial models to examine the association between functioning chlorinated water stations and the incidence of four of the five waterborne diseases: acute bloody diarrhea (ABD), acute other diarrhea (AOD), acute jaundice syndrome (AJS), and severe typhoid fever (STF). Dose-response models were used to investigate how the incidence of disease can theoretically be reduced as functioning and chlorinated water stations strategically increase. Compared to areas with lower quintiles of functioning and chlorinated water stations, the rates of the four waterborne diseases were lower in areas with higher quintiles of functioning and chlorinated water stations. Exposure to functioning water stations had a stronger association with lower rates of waterborne diseases than exposure to chlorinated water stations. Dose-response models demonstrate a potential for curbing the incidence of acute diarrhea and acute jaundice syndrome. The results of this study provide an understanding of the effects of water station functionality and chlorination in conflict settings. These findings support greater prioritization of WASH activities in countries experiencing violence against civilian infrastructure.
自2011年以来,叙利亚陷入了一场复杂的冲突,其特点是对平民和民用基础设施的袭击既有针对性又不分青红皂白。水利基础设施一直是攻击目标,这加剧了清洁饮用水的污染和获取问题,并增加了水传播疾病的风险。我们旨在确定在叙利亚西北部,使用更多功能正常且经过氯化处理的供水站是否与降低水传播疾病的风险相关。我们利用每周报告的疾病监测数据以及援助协调股(ACU)的水、环境卫生和个人卫生(WASH)系统评估计划的数据,研究了2017年1月1日至2021年6月30日期间,功能正常的氯化供水站对叙利亚西北部10个地区水传播疾病发病率的影响。我们运行了八个负二项式模型,以研究功能正常的氯化供水站与五种水传播疾病中的四种疾病发病率之间的关联:急性血性腹泻(ABD)、急性其他腹泻(AOD)、急性黄疸综合征(AJS)和重症伤寒热(STF)。剂量反应模型用于研究随着功能正常且经过氯化处理的供水站数量战略性增加,疾病发病率理论上如何降低。与功能正常且经过氯化处理的供水站处于较低五分位数的地区相比,处于较高五分位数的地区这四种水传播疾病的发病率较低。与接触经过氯化处理的供水站相比,接触功能正常的供水站与较低的水传播疾病发病率之间的关联更强。剂量反应模型表明有可能遏制急性腹泻和急性黄疸综合征的发病率。这项研究的结果有助于了解冲突环境中供水站功能和氯化处理的影响。这些发现支持在经历针对民用基础设施暴力的国家中,更加优先开展水、环境卫生和个人卫生活动。