Ahmed Aliya, Hoda Muhammad Qamarul, Shamim Faisal, Siddiqui Ali Sarfraz, Samad Khalid, Ismail Samina
The authors are in the Department of Anaesthesiology at Aga Khan University in Karachi, Pakistan. and are Professors; and are Associate Professors; is an Assistant Professor.
J Educ Perioper Med. 2023 Dec 27;25(4):E714. doi: 10.46374/volxxv_issue4_Ahmed. eCollection 2023 Oct-Dec.
Cricoid pressure (CP) is applied to occlude the esophagus during endotracheal intubation in patients at an increased risk of aspiration of gastric contents. Evidence shows marked deficiencies in knowledge and skills for CP application among personnel responsible for this task. This study evaluated the effectiveness of CP training in improving knowledge and skills regarding CP application among anesthesiology technicians and critical care nurses and assessed the retention of skills after 2 months.
Five workshops were conducted on effective application of CP. Indications, relevant anatomy, physiology, and correct technique were taught using interactive sessions and videos and hands-on practice on a weighing scale, 50-mL syringe, and trainer model. Pre- and postworkshop tests were conducted for knowledge and skill. An assessment was repeated after 2 months to assess skill retention.
Five workshops were conducted for 102 participants. Statistically significant improvements were seen in mean scores for knowledge in postworkshop assessments (12.32 ± 2.12 versus 7.12 ± 2.32; < .01). Similarly, posttraining mean scores for skill assessment were significantly higher than pretraining scores (6.31 ± 0.96 versus 2.72 ± 2.00; < .0005), indicating an overall 131% improvement. Seventy-four participants appeared for assessment of the retention of skills. A 20% decrement was observed compared with posttraining scores (5.15 ± 1.71 versus 6.45 ± 0.86; < .0005).
A significant improvement was observed in both knowledge and skills immediately following training. However, this does not ensure long-term retention of clinical skills, as a 20% decrement was observed 2 months after the workshops. Formal training and regular practice are recommended to enable clinicians to perform CP effectively.
在胃内容物误吸风险增加的患者进行气管内插管期间,应用环状软骨压迫(CP)来阻塞食管。有证据表明,负责此项任务的人员在CP应用的知识和技能方面存在明显不足。本研究评估了CP培训在提高麻醉技术人员和重症监护护士CP应用知识和技能方面的有效性,并评估了2个月后技能的保持情况。
举办了5次关于CP有效应用的研讨会。通过互动环节、视频以及在体重秤、50毫升注射器和训练模型上的实践操作,教授了CP的适应证、相关解剖学、生理学和正确技术。在研讨会前后分别进行知识和技能测试。2个月后重复评估以评估技能保持情况。
为102名参与者举办了5次研讨会。在研讨会后的评估中,知识的平均得分有统计学意义的提高(12.32±2.12对7.12±2.32;P<.01)。同样,培训后技能评估的平均得分显著高于培训前得分(6.31±0.96对2.72±2.00;P<.0005),表明总体提高了131%。74名参与者接受了技能保持情况的评估。与培训后得分相比,观察到技能下降了20%(5.15±1.71对6.45±0.86;P<.0005)。
培训后立即观察到知识和技能都有显著提高。然而,这并不能确保临床技能的长期保持,因为在研讨会2个月后观察到技能下降了20%。建议进行正规培训和定期练习,以使临床医生能够有效地实施CP。