The University of Texas at El Paso, USA.
University of Nevada, Reno, USA.
J Interpers Violence. 2024 Jul;39(13-14):3040-3061. doi: 10.1177/08862605231225518. Epub 2024 Jan 10.
Religion has had a mixed impact on society, with some followers engaging in violent behavior. It remains unclear why some followers perpetrate violence and others are peaceful. We argue that religious overclaiming is one facet of religion to be considered when trying to understand the relationship between religion and violence. Across two studies ( = 551), we tested the hypothesis that a higher tendency to overclaim knowledge of the Christian Bible would be associated with higher perpetration of intimate partner violence (IPV). We also tested the hypotheses that men who overclaim would be most likely to engage in the perpetration of IPV, and that higher religiosity would attenuate the effects of religious overclaiming. In both studies, participants completed a measure of religious overclaiming, reported on their perpetration of IPV, and reported their religiosity. Our findings across both studies indicated that Bible overclaiming was associated with greater perpetration of IPV. Further, Study 1 found that those high in Bible overclaiming (especially men) engaged in the most perpetration of IPV. However, this gender-based finding did not replicate in Study 2. Both studies found that religiosity was unassociated with the perpetration of IPV. Our results provide evidence that Bible overclaiming is related to the perpetration of IPV. Specifically, individuals who claim to know religious concepts that do not exist are associated with a higher risk for IPV.
宗教对社会的影响好坏参半,一些信徒的行为具有暴力性。目前还不清楚为什么有些信徒会实施暴力行为,而有些信徒则是和平的。我们认为,在试图理解宗教与暴力之间的关系时,需要考虑宗教过度宣称这一方面。通过两项研究(n=551),我们检验了这样一个假设,即更高的过度宣称对《圣经》知识的倾向与更高的亲密伴侣暴力(IPV)实施之间存在关联。我们还检验了以下假设:过度宣称的男性最有可能实施 IPV,而更高的宗教信仰会减弱宗教过度宣称的影响。在两项研究中,参与者都完成了一项关于宗教过度宣称的测量,报告了他们对 IPV 的实施情况,并报告了他们的宗教信仰。我们在两项研究中的发现都表明,对《圣经》的过度宣称与 IPV 的实施存在关联。此外,研究 1 发现,那些在《圣经》过度宣称方面得分较高的人(尤其是男性)实施的 IPV 最多。然而,这一基于性别的发现并没有在研究 2 中得到复制。两项研究都发现,宗教信仰与 IPV 的实施无关。我们的研究结果提供了证据表明,对《圣经》的过度宣称与 IPV 的实施有关。具体来说,那些声称了解不存在的宗教概念的人更有可能实施 IPV。