Egan K J, Beaton R
J Psychosom Res. 1987;31(1):11-21. doi: 10.1016/0022-3999(87)90093-6.
From the literature, it is clear that a small proportion of people account for an inordinately high number of health care visits. Conversely, there exists a group of individuals who rarely seek professional medical intervention and, yet, who remain healthy. This study examines a sample of adults who have not received remedial treatment for any symptom in the previous year, who consider themselves as healthy and who pass a comprehensive physical examination. A gender and age balanced group of healthy low utilizers was administered the Symptom Response Questionnaire, an instrument designed to elicit response tendencies to thirteen standardized symptoms. There were significant differences between age groups in response to symptoms with the older individuals more likely to seek professional help. There were few gender differences within the healthy sample. This sample of healthy low-utilizers was not without symptoms, reporting an average of 20 symptoms occurring in the previous week as measured by the SCL-90. A clinical headache group was also administered the SRQ to provide information about their response tendencies to symptoms. This preliminary study suggests that response to illness may be significantly influenced by age and patient status and that reported gender differences in health care utilization may need to be examined more carefully. It is proposed that behavior patterns of healthy, low utilizers may have direct implications for intervention with high utilizers of the health care system.
从文献中可以清楚地看到,一小部分人占用了极高比例的医疗就诊次数。相反,有一群人很少寻求专业医疗干预,但却保持健康。本研究考察了一组成年人样本,他们在过去一年中没有因任何症状接受过治疗,自认为健康且通过了全面体检。对一组性别和年龄均衡的健康低医疗利用率者进行了症状反应问卷调查,该问卷旨在引出对13种标准化症状的反应倾向。不同年龄组对症状的反应存在显著差异,年龄较大的个体更倾向于寻求专业帮助。在健康样本中,性别差异不大。这组健康低医疗利用率者并非没有症状,根据症状自评量表(SCL - 90)测量,他们报告在过去一周平均出现20种症状。还对一个临床头痛组进行了症状反应问卷调查,以了解他们对症状的反应倾向。这项初步研究表明,对疾病的反应可能受年龄和患者状况的显著影响,而且报告的医疗保健利用率方面的性别差异可能需要更仔细地研究。有人提出,健康低医疗利用率者的行为模式可能对医疗保健系统高医疗利用率者的干预有直接影响。