Su Jing Jing, Bayuo Jonathan, Lin Rose Sy, Batalik Ladislav, Chen Xi, Abu-Odah Hammoda, Chan Engle Angela
School of Nursing, The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hong Kong SAR, China.
School of Nursing, University of Rochester, NY, USA.
Nurs Ethics. 2024 Sep;31(6):1079-1091. doi: 10.1177/09697330231196226. Epub 2024 Jan 20.
eHealth was widely used during the COVID-19 pandemic. Much attention was given to the technical aspects of eHealth, such as infrastructure and cost, while the soft skill of compassion remained underexplored. The wide belief in compassionate care is more compatible with in-person interactions but difficult to deliver via e-platforms where personal and environmental clues were lacking urges studying this topic.
to explore the experience of delivering compassionate care via an eHealth platform among healthcare professionals working to contain the COVID-19 pandemic.
A qualitative study design with an interpretative phenomenological analysis approach was used. Twenty healthcare professionals (fifteen nurses and five physicians) who provided care using technology platforms, such as telephone hotlines, mobile apps, and social media, were interviewed individually.
Permission to conduct the study was obtained from the Institutional Review Board.
Participants stated that "eHealth enabled compassionate care during the pandemic" by ensuring patient care availability and accessibility. They shared experiences of "communicating compassionate care via eHealth" with suggestions of addressing patients' needs with empathy, adopting a structured protocol to guide eHealth communication, and using more advanced visual-media methods to promote human-to-human interaction. They recommended "setting realistic mutual expectations" considering the limitations of eHealth in handling complex health situations and staffing shortages. Participants considered "low eHealth literacy hinders compassion." Additionally, they recommended the need for "institutional/system-level support to foster compassionate care."
Participants recognized the importance of integrating compassion into eHealth services. Promotion of compassionate care requires standardization of eHealth services with institutional and system-level support. This also includes preparing adequate staffing who can communicate compassionate care via eHealth, set realistic expectation, and adjust communication to eHealth literacy level while meeting the needs of their patients.
在新冠疫情期间,电子健康技术得到了广泛应用。人们更多地关注电子健康的技术方面,如基础设施和成本,而同情心这一软技能仍未得到充分探索。人们普遍认为,富有同情心的护理更适合面对面互动,但在缺乏个人和环境线索的电子平台上却难以实现,这促使我们对这一主题进行研究。
探讨在抗击新冠疫情的医疗专业人员中,通过电子健康平台提供富有同情心护理的经验。
采用定性研究设计和解释性现象学分析方法。对20名使用电话热线、移动应用程序和社交媒体等技术平台提供护理的医疗专业人员(15名护士和5名医生)进行了单独访谈。
获得了机构审查委员会进行该研究的许可。
参与者表示,“电子健康在疫情期间实现了富有同情心的护理”,因为它确保了患者护理的可及性和可得性。他们分享了“通过电子健康传达富有同情心的护理”的经验,并提出了以同理心满足患者需求、采用结构化协议指导电子健康沟通以及使用更先进的视觉媒体方法促进人际互动的建议。他们建议“考虑到电子健康在处理复杂健康状况和人员短缺方面的局限性,设定现实的相互期望”。参与者认为“电子健康素养低会阻碍同情心的表达”。此外,他们建议需要“机构/系统层面的支持来促进富有同情心的护理”。
参与者认识到将同情心融入电子健康服务的重要性。促进富有同情心的护理需要在机构和系统层面的支持下对电子健康服务进行标准化。这还包括配备足够的人员,他们能够通过电子健康传达富有同情心的护理,设定现实的期望,并根据电子健康素养水平调整沟通方式,同时满足患者的需求。