Centre for Crime, Justice and Security, Staffordshire University, LW126 Ashley 2 Building, College Rd., Stoke-on-Trent ST4 2DE, UK.
Expert Citizens CIC, Federation House Station Road, Stoke on Trent ST4 2SA, UK.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2024 Jan 5;21(1):63. doi: 10.3390/ijerph21010063.
British drug policies could underserve women with treatment needs, and this paper provides evidence that communication through the words and actions of professionals across drug and alcohol services, health and mental health, social work and the criminal justice sector can leave women feeling stigmatised and failed. Women live with the stigma of 'the lying addict'; however, documents and courtroom statements provided by professionals can misrepresent women's experiences, which exacerbates social harm. Data are drawn from feminist participatory action research, where female lived experience experts worked alongside academics to implement a qualitative study using interviews and focus groups with women using treatment services (n = 28) and an online world café with professionals working with these women (n = 9) and further professionals providing support at lived experience data collection events (n = 5). This data set is cross-referenced with one-to-one and small-group interviews with professionals in the field (n = 17) conducted by a third-sector partner. Findings establish that stigma negatively impacts the identification of treatment needs and access to timely and appropriate service delivery. Social harms to women with addictions could be significantly reduced with timely, authentic, honest, gender-informed and trauma-informed practices for girls and women using drugs and alcohol to self-medicate from traumatic experiences.
英国的毒品政策可能无法满足有治疗需求的女性,本文提供的证据表明,毒品和酒精服务、卫生和心理健康、社会工作和刑事司法部门的专业人员通过言语和行动进行沟通,会让女性感到被污名化和被抛弃。女性承受着“说谎的瘾君子”的污名;然而,专业人员提供的文件和法庭陈述可能会歪曲女性的经历,从而加剧社会伤害。数据来自女性主义参与式行动研究,女性生活经历专家与学者合作,使用访谈和焦点小组对使用治疗服务的女性(n=28)进行定性研究,以及与这些女性一起开展在线世界咖啡馆(n=9),并在生活经历数据收集活动中得到其他专业人员的支持(n=5)。该数据集与第三方合作伙伴进行的领域内专业人员的一对一和小组访谈(n=17)交叉引用。研究结果表明,污名将对识别治疗需求和获得及时、适当的服务产生负面影响。如果对使用毒品和酒精来治疗创伤经历的女孩和女性进行及时、真实、诚实、性别敏感和创伤知情的实践,那么对有药物滥用问题的女性的社会伤害可以大大减少。