Rodwell Vanessa, Patil Manjiri, Kuht Helen J, Neuhauss Stephan C F, Norton William H J, Thomas Mervyn G
Ulverscroft Eye Unit, School of Psychology and Vision Sciences, University of Leicester, Leicester LE1 7RH, UK.
Department of Molecular Life Science, University of Zurich, 8006 Zurich, Switzerland.
Biology (Basel). 2023 Dec 20;13(1):4. doi: 10.3390/biology13010004.
Optokinetic reflex (OKR) assays in zebrafish models are a valuable tool for studying a diverse range of ophthalmological and neurological conditions. Despite its increasing popularity in recent years, there are no clear reporting guidelines for the assay. Following reporting guidelines in research enhances reproducibility, reduces bias, and mitigates underreporting and poor methodologies in published works. To better understand optimal reporting standards for an OKR assay in zebrafish, we performed a systematic literature review exploring the animal, environmental, and technical factors that should be considered. Using search criteria from three online databases, a total of 109 research papers were selected for review. Multiple crucial factors were identified, including larval characteristics, sample size, fixing method, OKR set-up, distance of stimulus, detailed stimulus parameters, eye recording, and eye movement analysis. The outcome of the literature analysis highlighted the insufficient information provided in past research papers and the lack of a systematic way to present the parameters related to each of the experimental factors. To circumvent any future errors and champion robust transparent research, we have created the zebrafish optokinetic (ZOK) reflex minimal reporting guideline.
斑马鱼模型中的视动反射(OKR)检测是研究多种眼科和神经疾病的重要工具。尽管近年来其应用越来越广泛,但该检测尚无明确的报告指南。在研究中遵循报告指南可提高可重复性、减少偏差,并减少已发表作品中的报告不足和方法不当问题。为了更好地了解斑马鱼OKR检测的最佳报告标准,我们进行了一项系统的文献综述,探讨应考虑的动物、环境和技术因素。使用来自三个在线数据库的搜索标准,共筛选出109篇研究论文进行综述。确定了多个关键因素,包括幼体特征、样本量、固定方法、OKR设置、刺激距离、详细的刺激参数、眼睛记录和眼动分析。文献分析结果突出了过去研究论文中提供的信息不足,以及缺乏系统呈现与每个实验因素相关参数的方法。为避免未来出现任何错误并倡导稳健透明的研究,我们制定了斑马鱼视动(ZOK)反射最小报告指南。